Thrift Stores near Wyckoff, NJ

23 locations found near Wyckoff
View Map

“PROS: this place was very nice. Historically a train station that was renovated into a shop. The staff was nice, prices were amazing, variety of items plentiful, everything was organized, and the items were good quality. There was even loads of parking CONS: the place wasn't all that big which caused congestion inside. OVERALL: I will definitely come back here as this is an amazing place to go thrifting”

3.5 Good5 Reviews

“came here for the furniture, and will come back for the staff!! EJ & Don, specifically, were SO kind, fun and full of light! the nicest people with the most genuine, loving energy!! ?”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“This place is absolutely incredible. I think I could spend 8 hours in here and not see everything. I was shocked at how big the space is, what a hidden treasure. I went in on a Saturday and it was a little busy but that's normal. The gentlemen working were two of the nicest guys I have ever met, which makes me want to shop here all the time. They were so kind with every customer. Once it was my turn, not only did one of the gentlemen wrap each one of my purchases in paper then boxed them, but when I got home I realized he also removed the tags, saving me that chore. I will be back - often.”

4.9 Superb21 Reviews

“I purchased a Barbie airplane for a great price, my daughter was ecstatic with the find. The gentleman behind the counter was polite and had a pleasant disposition. We hope to return in the near future, it certainly is a place for nostalgic treasures.”

4.9 Superb15 Reviews

“I made the trip up to Spring Valley just to visit this store. Worth it!! Beautiful designer dresses (saw an original Carolina Herrera dress) and great modest clothing in good condition. I spent about 2 1/2hrs there sorting through everything. You can try on in the bathroom.Of special note - because the clothes are mostly donated by the Hassidic/Orthodox Jewish Community you will find many dresses, skirts, pants etc. However the sizing is either XS/S or plus size. You have to really dig for mediums.”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

“This thrift store was absolutely AMAZING! The volunteers are so sweet, it feels as though you walked into a family gathering and were instantly brought into the family. The prices are such a bargain, and so many great vintage and new pieces alike! So well organized. Would recommend coming here again and again!”

4.7 Superb6 Reviews

“You have to go to passaic county restore great prices and very organized . And the friendliest staff . Left with a full carriage of many supplies needed for my home improvement job. Highly recommended.”

3.9 Good31 Reviews

“Stopped by today, and what a wonderful thrift shoppe. Walking in was like walking into my grandmother's house. Judith is very friendly, kind, and professional. It is worth the trip to Pompton Plains. Found nice custom jewelry and near mint condition clothes. What a nice shopping experience!”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“It may be odd to review a Goodwill store, but here it is! Found a few clothing treasures here- even my teens liked it. Apparently “retro clothing” is cool so we’re all happy! And money spent goes to a good cause.”

3.8 Good36 Reviews

“Definitely a hidden gem. I always find something great here. They have a great variety of items, everything is very well organized and fairly priced. The volunteers are very sweet and helpful and do a wonderful job.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“PROS: Very nice thrift store I just found the other day on Yelp. People that work there are very nice and there is great variety. The place is clean and organized with a lot of parking CONS: some of the stuff tends to be overpriced. The board games being notorious for that OVERALL: I definitely will come back here when I'm in the area. It's a nice thrift store non the less. I would just stay away from the board games”

3.9 Good14 Reviews

“Only problem here, ugh, is anytime that I go, there are no shopping carts available. Staff, which by the way are helpful, have no idea how or why they’re losing shopping carts. Ugh!!”

3.7 Good41 Reviews

“This Thrift Store serves the Community well. Their prices are reasonable and shoppers are able to find lovely garments and other household products there. Also, the management and staff are courteous, helpful and supportive.It's a very lovely Marketplace to shop, especially for shoppers who are looking for good stuff at reasonable prices. Visit this Marketplace if you're interested in finding a Thrift Store in Downtown, Paterson, NJ.”

3.7 Good3 Reviews

“I went here to look for some black pants for work, unfortunately I wasn't able to find anything that fit me. I'm a size 16, I wasn't able to find any parts over size 14. Most were 8 and 10 under. So if you're on the bigger side, I wouldn't be too hopeful about finding clothes here. They have quite a bit of a selection tho, I did find the curtains I was looking for and most prices are good. I saw a lot of clothes for 8 dollars under, and I saw a couple for 40$ plus. Overall a good place to go to for shirts and other miscellaneous stuff. I'll return again when I'm looking to refresh my closet.Edit: yes, it's true nothing is organized by size, only color, so be prepared to sort to the whole rack to find something in your size.”

3.4 Good48 Reviews

“Shoppers today may not believe this, but the building housing MyUnique Thrift Paterson is ACTUALLY 120 YEARS OLD! It's original purpose was as one of the first department stores in the history of downtown Paterson. It was originally known as Quackenbush and built to replace the original store which burned down in the Great Paterson Fire of 1902. Quackenbush took up six floors of the current building with each floor covering a different type of product. Walk to the middle of the current store, and you'll see a double spiral staircase. THAT IS THE ORIGINAL STAIRCASE. An architectural marvel. Although it has been refurbished several times, it has still held up over the decades. Today's store, while lacking the charm of the original, still pays homage to the spirit of Quackenbush. MyUnique Thrift Paterson has the standard of a true store of this kind. Good products at good prices. The service can be a bit impersonal but it's a different clientele these days.”

3.3 Good32 Reviews

“I've been a customer and consignor for many years. The owner knows her customers and due to the size of the shop she must be selective. Always find a treasure when I go ?46 years in business says it all!”

3 Average6 Reviews

“Amazingly large area located in an old factory the entrance is in the loading back area Parking's tight Prices are good but Wednesday's three tags great Got my winter wardrobe there Wednesday staff very helpful Try it u will like it”

2.8 Average4 Reviews

“It's hit or miss here...but always more hit than miss..I go for older appliances when counter mixers and grillers were made with real parts..not rubber and plastic”

1.7 Poor3 Reviews

“Prices are great got a brand new pack and play for $30!! But I wouldn't try to sell stuff to them because they are very picky and don't pay well. Better to donate to your local womans shelter.”

3.1 Average41 Reviews

“As far as I can tell there are only two Red, White and Blue thrift stores in the Northeast - one in Waterbury, Connecticut and this one in Paterson, New Jersey. I've made the journey to both locations multiple times and have yet to leave disappointed. Our latest excursion to the NJ location was no different. Right out of the gate, we got an unexpected bonus when we noticed a man selling tamales out of a cargo van in the parking lot. Now, if there's a better way to start off a thrift shopping sesh than with bootleg van food, I'm not aware of it. So we're obviously in for a treat. Both RWB locations are laid out pretty much the same with a massive selection of shoes up front followed by a housewares treasure trove that consists of what seems a like 50' long aisle strewn haphazardly with pots and dishes and smaller items in plastic bags. However, at the moment I'm pretty well set for nasty old Velcro sneakers and chipped depression glass and Bunnykins so we move to the real draw here - a half-century's worth of the moth-eaten sartorial discards of North Jersey's rustbelt. Now, I'll start by saying this is no suburban Goodwill or Plato's Closet and so if you're looking for nice-smelling North Face fleeces and Khakis, you're gonna be a stranger in a strange land. However, if you've come for corduroy and velvet blazers, bowling-themed garments, double-pocket polos, Western-themed snap-buttons, plaid golf slacks, padded hospital socks, paisley bathrobes, Barry Manilow t-shirts, vomit-hued cardigans or striped banlon, all grimy and caked up with that naphthalene and black mold-ridden thrift store goodness, then you are where you were meant to be. But of course stay outta my way because I'm tryna grab up all that nasty ass crap for myself. This day's haul included some great finds including many unfortunately-patterned sweaters and polos and a camel-skin blazer. But perhaps best of all - a custom T-shirt from a girl named Sophie's quince and the Brodhead Family's family reunion from 2015. However, the Holy Grail of the day's haul was without a doubt, the custom-printed Vince Vaughn collage sweatshirt. "You don't need that," sneered my wife when she saw it in the cart, though she must have known that I did in fact need it and there was zero chance I wasn't buying it.”

2.9 Average124 Reviews

“Best thrift shop in the area by far. Tagged prices can be high but be sure to look for the daily mark downs. Price tags are all color coded and every day three colors are picked to be 75%, 50%, and 25% off. Those mark down deals really can't be beat. The store usually very clean and organized. I've gotten some real treasures from value village!”

2.2 Poor48 Reviews