Grocery Stores near Cutchogue, NY

17 locations found near Cutchogue

“Excellent supermarket. Very nice and fresh produce section. Great cold cuts and prepared food. Meat section has good quality meats across the board. Nothing much in the way of fresh seafood; very little quantity and variety. There is also a nice florist area with greeting cards. Well stocked. Staff is OK. Could maybe use a bit of cheer and friendliness at checkout.”

4 Good110 Reviews

“I was having trouble finding red egg dye for our traditional Greek Easter Eggs. The generous person I spoke with was able to mail me a packet. I am grateful and will be visiting this wonderful establishment soon. Thank you!”

4.8 Superb68 Reviews

“So much great variety at this north fork gem! Great vegan options and n/a drinks. The curry cashews they carry are delicious! They also carry natural beauty supplies.”

4.9 Superb29 Reviews

“I've been a customer for at least 12 years now. They have the most deliciously flavored olive oils and vinegars. Blood orange olive oil, chocolate and blueberry balsamic vinegars are some robust delicious flavors. The owner Rita is very knowledgable and will help you sample the offerings so you can decide which you want to try. I was beyond surprised to learn that some of these products can be used with desserts. What a pleasant surprise. She also has some wares that you can combine with the oils and vinegars to create beautiful host and hostess gifts. There are several different sized bottles that you can fill with the oils and vinegars. The smallest would actually make nice party, shower or event favors.”

4.7 Superb45 Reviews

“IGA Southold is a convenient and dependable spot for groceries on the North Fork. They offer a good selection of fresh produce, meats, and pantry staples, especially considering its size. The deli is handy for quick lunch items. Prices are fair for the area, and the staff is consistently friendly and helpful. A solid, essential local market!”

4.3 Superb107 Reviews

“Really good quality produce at a fair price. I usually stop at this place on my way back from the north fork. Everything is fresh with a great selection of squashes. highly recommend.”

4.6 Superb37 Reviews

“i have been shopping at the hampton bays king kullen for close to 20 years. And although i will often shop at other grocery stores closer to where i live i have found the hampton bays king kullen overall provides the best service from the very courteous, helpful and smart and friendly knowledgeable staff most of whom have been there for as long as i’ve been going to the excellent quality of their produce and meat department. i give them 5 stars easily.”

4.2 Good171 Reviews

“(Please click on photo to see Wild by Nature at night). I have been shopping here almost daily since the day they opened. That's when I stopped visiting their East Setauket store, as this branch is much more convenient. The food is delicious. The store, including bathroom, is very clean. Cheaper conventional, as well as organic items, are available. It's great not having to read labels as much.....I trust them more than other stores for safe food. Everything is Non-GMO, for example, while elsewhere, buyer beware! The staff is terrific, all except one short, rude woman, and the deli offers fabulous dishes! Yes, this place is definitely expensive, but you won't find super-long checkout lines! The wide array of products and healthful foods make it worthwhile for me to shop here. Nutritious food is "preventative medicine".....eat right and stay out of trouble! I'm worth it. You're worth it.”

4.3 Superb94 Reviews

“I used to stop here all the time when I young. It has since changed hands and the types of food are far different than what I was used to. They have a lot of Spanish type foods and fresh seafood. I stopped in because I wanted a fresh brewed unsweet tea But they didn't have that. They only had it in bottles which is nasty to me so I didn't purchase anything in the store! I will stop here again I just won't be able to get tea.”

4.5 Superb11 Reviews

“Always clean, well stocked, and well organized—and since winter 2025, much more intuitively arranged!

Checkout lines sometimes get backed up.”

4.1 Good95 Reviews

“Small store, but very good inventory. Staffs great and pre-made foods also very delicious. People can complain all they want about the prices, but its literally the Hamptons. Definitely can find premium ingredients you wouldn't even normally find in other speciality stores (like some certain asian groceries).”

4 Good182 Reviews

“Very clean, employees are great. Excellent variety of food. Guaranteed to find what you want and prices are reasonable, considering it's in the 'Hamptons'”

3.9 Good126 Reviews

“Handy Pantry in Mattituck is special. Been going there for a sandwich for lunch since high school. They make great sandwiches and is a great stop for grabbing cold cuts and basic groceries. Some items are priced higher than a grocery store, but others are cheaper and everything is great quality. Plenty of beer too.”

3.5 Good23 Reviews

“This is such a funny/lovely little grocery.It reminded me of the small town grocery store from the 2007 flop, "The Mist." It also has shockingly good music playing throughout the store. I found myself dancing several times in the aisles only to catch of a glimpse of several other shoppers doing the same. What a riot!”

3.4 Good57 Reviews

“Very impressive market, the produce department was the largest of any store I know with more choices of fresh vegetables and fruits that were at prices that beat any Riverhead shops. I found the employees and checkout staff very friendly. I brought home enough dinner with 4 people for $28.00.”

3.6 Good118 Reviews

“As someone who shops here for personal and small business needs, I’m very impressed with this location. I can see the staff work hard to keep everything organized and clean as best as possible. As a local I noticed the influx of people when another grocery store closed and this S&S has adapted well and made necessary changes. Glad to see a lot of variety, especially the free-from options. Thank you and keep it up!”

3.6 Good134 Reviews

“Wayside has all the best attributes of an old-school butcher - great cuts of meat, encyclopedic knowledge of how to cook them and impeccable service - plus the local farm connections and amazing prepared foods you would find in a high-end market. The deli is a great stop for delicious sandwiches at reasonable prices; the butcher is a place to find extraordinary locally sourced meat or - more economically - a unique burger blend. Must-stop for grilling on the north fork.”

3.3 Good174 Reviews

Related topics