Hotels near Fire Island, NY

10 locations found near Fire Island
View Map

“For years I had hear about the white looking castle building on cherry grove, The Belvedere Guest House, (men only). So I book for one night only, just to test the waters, well....I believe I should have book for at least three days. The place have a welcome spirit the minute you walk in. A friendly staff await at you (Jason Justin, Miguelito Sunny and rest) thank you guys. The patrons are handsome men of all ages having a good time all day. the place is clean 24 o 7.My favorite spot for my sun bath was the upper deck. I planning to visit again.Nearby activities: Bay view and sunset it amazing, walking distance to beach is only 8 min. and 10 min to a list off shopping store, restaurant, bars and night club.”

4 Good38 Reviews

“My husband and I spent a week here in September. We had a wonderful experience. The room was a good size and had been recently renovated and decorated. There was plenty of space and the king bed was very comfortable.The staff were very caring and easy to speak with. We even got phone calls to be sure we were not lacking anything.I will surely stay here the next time I visit my friend in the area.”

4.6 Superb30 Reviews

“Perfect stay. Great, nice & professional staff. Very clean. Nice rooms. Central to shops & restaurants. Discounts at many restaurants. Loved using their bikes before we had to leave. Very helpful w luggage & ferry info during a weekend when the roads were all flooded.”

3.9 Good45 Reviews

“Best hotel on fire island! The staff is amazing, especially ED! I felt like I was part or the family. I was overwhelmed with their accommodations & service, highly recommend. Ed, thank you for being amazing! I will be back 10/10”

3.3 Good36 Reviews

“I love staying here whenever I want to stay the night on Fire Island. Jeff is an absolute pleasure and more than accommodating. The room is cute and always clean and the price is reasonable for the island. Also it's in prime area so whats not to love about that? I will be returning ! The negative reviews here make me smile at how much people complain :)”

2.9 Average19 Reviews

“I was respectfully greeded when I approached to reserve a room. The environment was very calm and clean. The plants that surrounded me as I was conversating with the employee to reserve my room....... were all wonderfully "real" and watered to a healthy perfection. When I opened the door to my room...... I was once again very pleased...... because everything was to the standards and clean. The carpet was vacuumed and clean and the bed was neatly prepped with clean covers (also checked the sheets because why not) and...... once again pleasingly clean with a pleasant fragrance of cleanliness. Thank you. For a truly comfortable, peaceful and affordable stay. I was facing a very challenging presentation the next day and I am actually being honest and thankful for my stay at the MacArthur inn...... I am a hard working mother who has three wonderful children and my job unfortunately requires me to travel and sometimes on my own dime and I genuinely always wish there would be a genuine, honest and clean, affordable stay inn's and this was exactly what I imagine. The next day on my presentation I truly aced my goals! All because all the expenses and frustrations were swift away with the honesty of MacArthur inn!Thank you..... sincerely E.S”

2.7 Average11 Reviews

“Basic room. Bring your own ice soap and shampoo. Other reviews are accurate. Had everything we needed. Thank you. Purchase room on Groupon or Rodeway Inn website for the best price.Nearby activities: Great food and coffee nearby.”

2.6 Average16 Reviews

“Very small roadside inn. We heard from the locals the motel was rough but we were pleasantly surprised. The room was nice in good shape fine for just a one night stay. Centrally located and the staff is nice.”

2.3 Poor33 Reviews

“Very nice. It's nice surroundings. Nice and quiet. Nice rooms . Good room service.Rooms: The rooms are very nice . It was great sleepNearby activities: Lots of store's. Places to eat. Great locationFood & drinks: Food and drinks where good”

2 Poor27 Reviews

“This hotel doesn't get good ratings and I don't know why. This hotel is immaculate! The service is wonderful and the staff is friendly. They have a continental breakfast which has an assortment of food. We have stayed here four times now in the last week and I won't stay anywhere else!! I definitely recommend!!!”

2.4 Poor108 Reviews