Hotels near Sayville, NY

“My husband and I spent a week here in September. We had a wonderful experience. The room was a good size and had been recently renovated and decorated. There was plenty of space and the king bed was very comfortable.The staff were very caring and easy to speak with. We even got phone calls to be sure we were not lacking anything.I will surely stay here the next time I visit my friend in the area.”

“I love staying here whenever I want to stay the night on Fire Island. Jeff is an absolute pleasure and more than accommodating. The room is cute and always clean and the price is reasonable for the island. Also it's in prime area so whats not to love about that? I will be returning ! The negative reviews here make me smile at how much people complain :)”

“Everything was great. The place is huge and appears to be recently renovated. This is one of the few places I've stayed that has an actual bathroom fan which, as some may know, is very helpful when there are multiple people using the facilities. The only complaint is the shower curtain is too short. I know it seem a trivial thing to complain about but the floor floods when you shower, making housekeeping's job that much more difficult than it needs to be.”

“All in all this is a great hotel. Pool was nice and very clean, the gym was nice and there were lots of equipment to workout with, the breakfast was decent and the kids really enjoyed themselves. The laundry area was the only thing that needed improvement. one washer was out of order and one dry made lots of noise and didn't dry well.Rooms: The room was so spacious and clean.”

“Conveniently located in Hauppauge. Many eateries nearby. Ample parking. Easy access to all highways. The suite has ample room. Clean. The breakfast is mediocre but I don’t expect better. I am rating on a scale relative to what this is. Don’t expect more.”

“For years I had hear about the white looking castle building on cherry grove, The Belvedere Guest House, (men only). So I book for one night only, just to test the waters, well....I believe I should have book for at least three days. The place have a welcome spirit the minute you walk in. A friendly staff await at you (Jason Justin, Miguelito Sunny and rest) thank you guys. The patrons are handsome men of all ages having a good time all day. the place is clean 24 o 7.My favorite spot for my sun bath was the upper deck. I planning to visit again.Nearby activities: Bay view and sunset it amazing, walking distance to beach is only 8 min. and 10 min to a list off shopping store, restaurant, bars and night club.”

“Perfect stay. Great, nice & professional staff. Very clean. Nice rooms. Central to shops & restaurants. Discounts at many restaurants. Loved using their bikes before we had to leave. Very helpful w luggage & ferry info during a weekend when the roads were all flooded.”

“Great rooms, recently renovated, nice appliances. Breakfast is pretty solid too. Nothing out of the ordinary but above your average hotel at this price.I'm giving location a 5 because it was really close to my business trip location. I assume you may be in a similar position if booking here.”

“I recently had the opportunity to stay at Bluewaters that left a positive impression on me. From the moment I arrived, I was greeted by a friendly and accommodating staff who made me feel welcome throughout my stay.One of the standout features of this hotel is its excellent location. Situated right in the center of town, within walking distance to all the shops, restaurants and the beach. Whether I was in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely shopping spree, everything I needed was conveniently close by.Upon entering my room, I was pleased to find a clean and well-maintained space. The housekeeping staff did an exceptional job in ensuring that the room was spotless and comfortable.The hotel also offered a range of amenities that enhanced my stay. Free beach chairs, umbrellas, towels, and free use of bikes are a definite added bonus.Throughout my stay, the staff consistently went above and beyond to ensure my needs were met. They were always available to answer any questions or provide recommendations, making me feel valued as a guest- Thank you Harvey!”

“Great place I booked 2 rooms and I enjoyed our stay as a family.Hotel very clean staff awesome there’s nothing negative that I can say.Pool water warm rooms clean and hallways clean.”

“Best hotel on fire island! The staff is amazing, especially ED! I felt like I was part or the family. I was overwhelmed with their accommodations & service, highly recommend. Ed, thank you for being amazing! I will be back 10/10”

“I was respectfully greeded when I approached to reserve a room. The environment was very calm and clean. The plants that surrounded me as I was conversating with the employee to reserve my room....... were all wonderfully "real" and watered to a healthy perfection. When I opened the door to my room...... I was once again very pleased...... because everything was to the standards and clean. The carpet was vacuumed and clean and the bed was neatly prepped with clean covers (also checked the sheets because why not) and...... once again pleasingly clean with a pleasant fragrance of cleanliness. Thank you. For a truly comfortable, peaceful and affordable stay. I was facing a very challenging presentation the next day and I am actually being honest and thankful for my stay at the MacArthur inn...... I am a hard working mother who has three wonderful children and my job unfortunately requires me to travel and sometimes on my own dime and I genuinely always wish there would be a genuine, honest and clean, affordable stay inn's and this was exactly what I imagine. The next day on my presentation I truly aced my goals! All because all the expenses and frustrations were swift away with the honesty of MacArthur inn!Thank you..... sincerely E.S”

“? The most brightly lit hotel room I have ever had. Reading and composing was so much better during my stay.❤️❤️❤️ I very much enjoyed the free hot breakfast buffet. Excellent biscuits, great blackberry compote, vegetarian sausage (heart friendly and delicious), three cheese egg soufflé muffins …. So much better than the hot breakfast choices at other Marriott brand hotels I have stayed at.Mediterranean cooking involves never combining fats and carbs in the same meal. One or the other.Proteins and fat choices available. Separate from carbs and veggie choices.Chef did an excellent job of providing healthy delicious choices.Very safe feeling throughout this area. No homeless seen anywhere. NOT having human body stench lingering on walkways in villages has been noticeable. The school systems and parents are doing something right to prevent homelessness.There are no ocean views from the hotel. Trees on the South, and industrial buildings mixed with trees on the North side. However, the central location is great to explore from.‼️ Drive the posted Speed Limits, police are very active here.Centrally located on Long Island, we drove to Montauk Point and lighthouse. The Atlantic Ocean is calming; see attached video. There is quite a bit of upscale 1930s style architecture on Long Island.Patchogue city is nearby and is a nice town full of restaurants and a few coffee shops.Recommended local restaurant:Lindo Mexico, Mexican restaurant58 S Ocean Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772Lindo Mexico restaurant had a very good vegetarian option. Vegetarian corn and jalapeño Tamales, and their Vegetarian burritoMixing bites of tamales with forked bites of burrito was very delicious.The table green sauce (not spicy) was good, and I used 1/2 a bottle on my meal. I also used a lesser amount of the table hot sauce, also better than usually found in a restaurant.The Tamarind soda was a welcome new flavor experience for me.My stay here continues to be enjoyable.”

“Jake's is my favorite casino that's located near NYC. Everything I needed is on site. They do need to upgrade their parking situation.Rooms: Rooms pretty nice, roomy and clean.Food & drinks: Main restaurant is pretty good with good service.”

“Basic room. Bring your own ice soap and shampoo. Other reviews are accurate. Had everything we needed. Thank you. Purchase room on Groupon or Rodeway Inn website for the best price.Nearby activities: Great food and coffee nearby.”

“The Hilton Garden Inn MacArthur Airport is overall a great hotel! The only complaints I could have is some minor things that need fixing in the rooms like a the bathroom door could use some new paint and some repairs of chipping on the middle bed side shelf. This is a great place for businesses trips as they provide you with a in room Ethernet connection. There is no communal business center as it mentions on their website. There is just a printer but no computers but there is plenty of space to set up your computer in your room and to connect to the WiFi through the Ethernet. The lobby is absolutely beautiful and gorgeous, they have a snack place for snacks for purchase and even a restaurant! The only thing that would make this hotel the best ever is an indoor pool! That would make an amazing addition. It would be great if they would include the breakfast and parking in the price of your room. This hotel is also very pet friendly!Safety: The safety is top notch with the main doors to the lobby being locked through the main hours of the night and all other entrances locked 24/7 where you have to have a keycard to unlock it. The only thing that I could note is it seemed like the windows in the hallways and the room could be opened.Food & drinks: They had many options in the little snack shop in the lobby and a full restaurant also.”

“Very small roadside inn. We heard from the locals the motel was rough but we were pleasantly surprised. The room was nice in good shape fine for just a one night stay. Centrally located and the staff is nice.”

“This hotel doesn't get good ratings and I don't know why. This hotel is immaculate! The service is wonderful and the staff is friendly. They have a continental breakfast which has an assortment of food. We have stayed here four times now in the last week and I won't stay anywhere else!! I definitely recommend!!!”