Jewelry Stores near Lancaster, NY

30 locations found near Lancaster
View Map

“JC Coins is top notch left with a couple nice late date large cents and a 1944 Henny counterfeit Nickel had a cup of coffee and some homemade chocolate like stepping back in time to an old school coin shop fair and honest thanks JC”

4.5 Superb23 Reviews

“I needed a clasp repaired on a chain that I received from my son when he was a teenager, 20 years ago. I needed to have it repaired rather quickly, in time for my daughter's wedding. My son, who is a wounded warrior, was returning home for the wedding and I wanted him to see the necklace that he had given me long ago. Garelick Jewelers repaired the clasp and had it ready for me before expected. They did a wonderful job and, as always, pricing for the repair was very considerate.Garelick Jewelers is more than 30 minutes from my home and I pass many other jewelers on my way there. Believe me, Ben Garelick Jewelers is worth the trip.”

5 Superb139 Reviews

“Beautiful selection of jewels all stones and metals. Great place for a custom engagement ring. I like that they also have talented jewelers who can advise, fix, clean, and size your precious pieces.”

5 Superb100 Reviews

“Barbara is the BEST!! She is honest and will help guide you for what’s best for you. I refer everyone to her and get compliments on my pieces all the time. She will be my jeweler as long as she’s in business.”

4.9 Superb140 Reviews

“Ryan is very trustworthy and the whole experience shopping with him was very enjoyable. He is able to source anything you are looking for. His prices are very competitive, and his jewelry is beautiful quality. I will be back!”

5 Superb73 Reviews

“Dave and Rachel are the best! We decided to elope on our anniversary instead of doing the big wedding and I ordered a ring at my local jeweler, and after multiple issues there and being told the wrong ring came in, I was left having to find a ring by Sunday night (with it being Friday). I called multiple places and was told they only had stock size and wouldn’t be able to resize it for me in that short amount of time, and went to countless jewelry stores to see they hardly had any rose gold wedding bands and even if I liked one of the few styles they wouldn’t be able to size it in time. Finally I came across Jeweler’s Studio and talked to Dave on the phone and told him everything and he was willing to see me right away and reassured me they could help. I came in Saturday am and was greeted by the two of them and they took the time to let me try on all of the rose gold rings (the biggest selection I have seen anywhere) and they even cleaned and polished my engagement ring on top of it! I ended up leaving with two rings because I wanted to stack rings and one was more of an anniversary gift, and Dave custom sized them right there in front of us!”

5 Superb69 Reviews

“A store full of beautiful jewelry! I can always find several pieces I would love to have. Very friendly and helpful customer service. Amy is very helpful but there is no pressure. I love all three of the beautiful rings I have purchased here as well as the beautiful necklace I purchased for my birthday. You won’t be disappointed if shop here.”

4.9 Superb99 Reviews

“I had a ring repaired/resized. It fit perfect when I picked it up it was polished and so clean, I almost didn’t recognize it. And of course Jim and the staff were all very friendly.I wouldn’t even think of going to a different jewelry store.”

4.9 Superb94 Reviews

“Amazing store with a wide variety of gift options for everyone on your list. They have a great bulk food and candy selection as well. The owners, Paul and Sandy are the best!”

4.8 Superb159 Reviews

“Been shopping here for the past five years. Quality of their jewelry is unquestioned. Bought a necklace for my daughter for Christmas. She actually would’ve preferred earrings which they happily exchanged for her. No must no fuss no problems I would highly recommend Andrew jewelers”

4.8 Superb122 Reviews

“What a great experience! Custom wedding bands within a week! The owner, Jim, was happy to teach us about the process of making the bands and kept us in the loop of the timeline. I know where I’ll be going for more jewelry:)”

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

“Doug is the best in the business. My husband bought many pieces from him including my one of a kind engagement ring at a great price. We couldn't be happier!”

4.9 Superb49 Reviews

“This place is dangerous. Every time I go in here I find something unique and special and gorgeous that I absolutely MUST have. Sarah is lovely and knowledgeable. I highly recommend.”

4.8 Superb69 Reviews

“Kim was very patient with me and my fiancé s we did not know exactly what we wanted and she showed us many different rings until we found what we liked and last minute I decided to upgrade and Kim was so helpful and explained everything and how it worked with upgrades we enjoyed our experience with Kim! Thank you so much”

5 Superb33 Reviews

“Can't say enough good things about this place. The owners are some of the nicest people in the world. Their jewelry is priced very good. Highly recommend them.”

4.8 Superb53 Reviews

“The kindest , patient and most experienced person I have ever dealt with it. His knowledge and honesty are the most valuable qualities in this industry . In Bill you have this and more ! Check him out for ALL your diamond needs.”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews

“Very professional when you go in there they right away greet you honest prices you don't have nothing and you explain that I'm the reason why you're there I know this by experience they help me out multiple times when I needed it I suggest if you have gold coins are silver go sell it to them because it will give you top dollar will treat you like family once you get to know them”

4.9 Superb35 Reviews

“Graeber did a wonderful job looking at and repairing my watch. I brought in an everday Casio G-Shock watch that had a recent battery replacement and was no longer making any sound. Ben talked to me about the watch and worked on it. Afterward, the watch started working properly. I’m grateful for Ben’s time and for both employees’ time and energy. I felt comfortable there, they were honest with me, and they were generous with their time and work—thank you!”

4.7 Superb70 Reviews

“Cute store where you can find decorations, gifts, and even clothes. However, everything is incredibly expensive.I preferred the other location as it added a special touch to the atmosphere and they seemed to have a larger selection.”

4.7 Superb58 Reviews

“This store is fantastic. The owner is very honest, knowledgeable and most importantly trustworthy. Anytime I stop by he’s always accommodating, friendly and reasonable. I’m perfectly comfortable doing business with him.”

4.9 Superb27 Reviews

“My husband bought my diamond post earrings for my Christmas gift last year! I absolutely love my earrings! My husband was so pleased with the help he received when he shopped and made his purchase.”

4.8 Superb33 Reviews

“It was a pleasure dealing with this business and their staff. Although I started with the female who was pleasant and professional, we/I worked/communicated mostly with Al. I had a custom "J" made and he reached out to me with pictures INCLUSIVE with measurements for my approval, before the work began, during the custom process, and afterwards.GREAT EXPERIENCE! EXCEPTIONAL CUSTOMER SERVICE. A rare trait in businesses today!Thank you to the staff. Keep up the exceptional work.”

4.6 Superb80 Reviews

“What started out as a great experience ended in almost a terrible one. I’ve been here for 2 hrs without the ring I purchased through Acima. We had to call them 4 times because they kept screwing up and ended up telling me I had to cancel the lease and try another time. I already spent the $76 initial payment and didn’t have another $76 to spend to start the lease all over again. As I was crying and about to leave with no ring no nothing, Abbi told me do the Acima lease again. I told him I trust you I just don’t trust Acima!!! They already took my money I signed their stupid contract 4 times and nothing. He said try again I’ll cash app you $80. He did as was promised and dropped my ring price down even more on top of that! WITH the warranty too! This customer service is absolutely exceptional, they will go above and beyond for you. Abbi , Sage and Olivia, all did so much for me today!!! Come to Mandati Jewelers!!! They won’t disappoint :)”

4.6 Superb75 Reviews

“Sold an engagement ring to them. It was a super easy experience and took them less than 10 minutes to examine and offer me a price which was extremely fair.10/10 recommend.”

4.6 Superb59 Reviews

“It’s very rare that I leave any reviews but I would be remiss if I didn’t state how welcome the staff made me feel. Kim, Jackie, LaShauna and Maureen , thank you so much for an incredible experience. The workmanship that goes into these products are simply stunning. If you’re into quality rather than quantity this is the best place to get handbags, shoes and jewelry!Thank you once again!”

4.9 Superb20 Reviews

“This was the cutest boutique ever! The staff were super personable and helpful. I actually ended up going back the same day to buy some thing else because I loved it so much!”

4.9 Superb19 Reviews

“Brought in a Skagen watch that I love but the battery kept going dead every few months. Turns out the last place (in the northtowns) replacing the battery did not seal it properly and now it is as good as new. Reasonable price, and the staff were friendly and helpful as well, def recommend!”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews

“The customer service and employees are the friendliest and happiest of all the bunch in this conglomerate (along with Research and Design). I feel welcome and comfortable when I shop there. They are great about calling (and texting) you when an item comes in. Thanks ladies, for loving your jobs and customers!”

4.9 Superb15 Reviews

“All I can say is - WOW! Elliott went above and beyond creating custom earrings for me with diamonds and my sons’ birthstones. He listened to what I wanted and delivered 200%! The project turned out better than I could have ever imagined. Many thanks to Winter Jewelry!”

5 Superb12 Reviews