Toy Stores near Massapequa, NY

24 locations found near Massapequa

“Stopped in during Easter weekend and was amazed at the inventory this store has. If there’s a line of toys / collectibles you want it’s inside these walls. Owner was very kind and helpful while shopping. Even if you’re not interested in buying something this is an amazing experience just to walk through. A truly museum grade collection and worth checking out. Will definitely be back thanks!”

3.9 Good99 Reviews

“I went to the place and was greeted very nicely and I was looking for an exchange of a game because the GameStop I got my game from gave me a broken disc case. Even though he just couldn’t exchange it. He gave me the right cover case with the art work very politely and I was really happy. Everything also is in place and there are a ton of games. Would definitely recommend.”

3.7 Good68 Reviews

“An amazing toy store. A great selection of educational toys and games. If you are looking for something different for a child’s party this is the place to come.
Beautiful gift baskets also available.
Owner and staff are very helpful, store is spotless and so organized. Owner also very community minded giving gift baskets for local fundraisers.
Definitely recommend this local Toy Store
Great place to shop”

4.8 Superb37 Reviews

“I love this place. There’s just something about walking into a bookstore and smelling the brewing coffee that feels special. The cafe is also super clean and the staff is knowledgeable and also helpful.”

4.7 Superb145 Reviews

“My favorite place on Long Island! I grew up in Lindenhurst and it’s so amazing to have a spooky place that would’ve made my teen years infinitely better. This place is so inclusive, welcoming and warm, the community the owner has built is so refreshing to see. Every time I walk in there’s so many new things and I am so happy to see it grow!”

4.7 Superb45 Reviews

“Fun stuff toys is our go to toy store. Our physical go to toy store I should say. There aren't many toy stores around anymore… I remember growing up we had Toys "R" Us we had KB toys. We had a bunch of different toy options but then again, that was before Amazon… It's nice to bring my son to an actual physical toy store and see him experience the way I used to at Toys "R" Us even my two older kids had Toys "R" Us but now Everybody orders everything off of Amazon or online… But if you want to bring your child to an actual physical toy store, just like what we used to have growing up this would be the place to go! Sure it is a quite a bit smaller than the toy stores we used to have, but again at least there is one physical place you can bring them to strictly designated to toys. The prices obviously are a little bit higher than what you would pay on Amazon for a specific toy, I know because I've done it while in the store and saw a significant difference in pricing… But I feel like you're paying for the experience also, if that even makes sense. It's nice to be able to bring your child and see him or her. Enjoy the toys before you actually purchase them. I would highly recommend fun stuff toys not because of the pricing, because it's significantly higher, but just to watch your children enjoy their shopping experience in an actual toy store. They have a great selection, the store itself is always very clean, and we can spend an hour or two just walking around the store even though it's smaller because of the experience, they will receive while shopping. I love seeing that continuous smile on his face, moving from toy to toy and actually trying them out before the actual purchase. To me, the smile, and the laughter of my child is worth every single penny!”

4.7 Superb108 Reviews

“This is my favorite comic store. Peter, the owner is incredibly knowledgeable and ready to recommend new reads as well as classic comics of all genres.

If you’re looking to start a weekly subscription, or add that special book you’ve always wanted, Phoenix Comics should be your first stop!

Thank you for a continually wonderful experience, Peter!”

4.8 Superb64 Reviews

“What kid doesn't love going to the LEGO STORE. Wish I had enough money to buy all the sets my kids want. So many sets I want for myself! Lego is part educational, so I'd much rather spend money on Legos than some toy that will end up in the basement. (Photo of special event cat)”

4.4 Superb88 Reviews

“First time in today! They had the cutest things. I was upset I was in a rush to get to the airport. I wanted to look around, I wanted one of everything!The whole store is very inviting, clean organized! I was shocked to see that in a card and gift store. the woman at checkout who helped me sign up for the rewards program was super sweet can't wait to go back!”

4.7 Superb43 Reviews

“Best place to be for rare, hard, to find collectibles!!! They have everything from DC, Marvel, Star Wars figures, and a good handful of Star Trek figs and Micro Machines. Carl is the man and would definitely come back here!”

4.5 Superb74 Reviews

“Stopped in here while waiting for a table at a nearby restaurant. This place is adorable and has lots of chic and one of a kind things! I bought a bunch of their Christmas items which were 50% off and some dainty gold rings. They have really cute stuff for women, candles, jewelry, baby items, accessories. Melanie was so sweet and helpful and even wrapped a gift for someone. Will definitely be back!”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“I love this variety card and gift store. They have almost everything including lottery. I never walk out without buying something. There Willow Tree collection is so up to date. I love gazing at them. Of course I buy one here and there. There cards are plentiful and beautiful. Have fun there.”

4.6 Superb38 Reviews

“We had a great experience today making a bear for my son’s first birthday! A very special thanks to Amanda for being so kind and accommodating for us! Will definitely be back!”

4.5 Superb51 Reviews

“Don't be fooled by the seemingly small storefront - this toy store has so much selection inside and so neatly organized. My kids and I were warmly greeted upon entering and offered help. Staff were all so friendly and kind. Great place to buy gifts for kids' birthday parties. I especially loved that they carry Usborne activity books!”

4.2 Good46 Reviews

“I don't go frequently but it's always a nice break for me. Good variety. Good staff. Appreciate Ya'll for allowing this guy to revisit an old hobby from back when. ???”

4.1 Good74 Reviews

“Keep in mind that the merchandise really doesn't make the store. They are all cookie-cutter stores. For me, it's the salespeople. The Freeport store has a nice young man who is quite helpful making my shopping easier.”

4 Good93 Reviews

“The main reason for this 5 star review is for Wilson who helped me put together a beautiful wedding arrangement of $200. His attention to detail, commitment and communication skills are incredible.Unfortunately, door dash delivery was a complete disaster. The 2 most expensive ballons were already deflated along with 4 other balloons. They wrapped the bags around our lamp post and broke of the tge lamps. He strongly suggest to pick up your Ballon arrangements.”

4 Good89 Reviews

“Harry and his beautiful family's please keep up the wonderful work you are doing in the community you guys always let everyone that come through the door feel welcome with a smile and most of all you know most of your customers by name keep on serving the community.”

4 Good5 Reviews

“Heard about this store from the LI Teachers group on FB. Greatest little find. Store has teacher supplies throughout but most of it is concentrated in the back. The woman at the register is extremely helpful. If you can’t find something, just ask her, she will let you know if they have any more in the back or if the are ordering more supplies. They also laminate anything you buy for free. Plus teachers get a 15% discount. Great store and customer service.”

3.9 Good41 Reviews

“Love coming here Everytime, the prices are very cheap and service is excellent from the father info to the Girls getting what you need and cashing you out. They never miss and always have what im looking for. 1000% recommend”

3.7 Good83 Reviews

“AJ was one of the kindest and most down to earth kind hearted toy collector and toy lover and fellow toy enthusiast as me! I felt super welcome! Ended up staying for four hours! Definitely will come back! AJ is super cool would love to meet Rob the owner ! Found some awesome stuff definitely a lot of vintage goodies and collectible memorabilia and toy haven!”

2.9 Average48 Reviews

“A wild and dangerous store in a good way! This store has an abundance of unique sugar options, items ive never seen before.it's definitely easy to get carried away. Overall it was fun experience but a lot of the exposed gummies that you grab and go are extremely old and hard. I'm not sure how often they clean it out but they need to start doing that more often.”

3.2 Average138 Reviews

“Many thanks to Andrea for making my daughter’s first visit on her second birthday so special!! She was amazing as was all the staff. We will definitely be back!!”

3.4 Good150 Reviews

“Great selection of cards ranging from yugioh, magic, Pokémon and tons more. Friendly community and the staff are always ready to help you with whatever you need.”

3.2 Average176 Reviews