Hotels in New Paltz, NY

“We found this hidden gem for our first wedding anniversary in 2016 and have been coming back ever since (now with two kids). Each time it gets better and better. Maria and Joe are divinely chill — think of your favorite cool Aunt and Uncle. The accommodations are exquisitely comfy and chic and Maria’s breakfasts are to kill for (no joke — try to get in between me and my plate at your own risk ?)... on a scale of 1 to 5, Mountain Meadows is at least a 7.5…”

“Let me start by saying I love Mohonk Mountain House and have been familiar with it since the early 1980's. While over the years we have often visited for lunch, hiking, had family gatherings there and even had my sister's wedding there, this past week is the first time my husband and I stayed there since the 1980's. (I found photos from 100+ years ago when my grandmother's family visited.) I have watched it get even better over the years but our autistic daughter caused us to not be able to stay overnight since the 1980's. She went into a group home so we were finally able to stay once again.My husband has food allergies which act like a contact allergy (similar to poison ivy). Bell pepper is extremely irritating to his digestive system even in a minute quantity. Something he ate set this off despite warning staff and trying to be very careful. This caused him to be out of commission so I did things by myself.I know I am not a foodie. I enjoyed the offerings for breakfast and lunch, but dinner was a problem for me. I found it hard to find something I really liked on the menu. I particularly had a problem with the Gemelli Bolognese. I very much like a bolognese so happily ordered it. I felt like I was eating a very spicy, mouth burning Mexican dish. I couldn't eat much of it and was VERY disappointed. It never listed any addition of heat and was NOT a nice surprise.The beds were wonderful. I enjoyed the antiques sprinkled through out the place. Staff was very friendly and helpful. It was so nice to see the care taken and familiarity with the place. I just wish if heat/red pepper were added to a dish or offering it was noted. (There was possible also a problem with bacon at breakfast since cut pieces could be bacon and some seemed to have a heat to it. This might have been what caused the problem for my husband.)”

“Such a great hotel! Very cozy, quiet, and affordable. The staff were excellent and made me feel very welcome. I loved the binder full of information and the channel list! Well informed and the room smelled amazing!! The cleaning crew is phenominal! Overall such a great stay and will definitely be back! Thank you!”

“The room seemed to have been renovated lately and they were clean. They were also pretty spacious. There was a microwave and a coffeemaker in the room, but you can also get (kinda good) coffee in the lobby. The staff were efficient and polite, so no complaints from my side. The only thing was, that there weren't a lot of choices to eat, so we had to drive to the nearest town. A minor inconvenience as it was pretty nice otherwise.Rooms: Renovated and clean.Food & drinks: You have to drive to the nearest town for good options.”