Hotels near Shelter Island, NY

12 locations found near Shelter Island

“My bff and I came to Pridwin for a girls weekend. The hotel and amenities are beautiful, but really made a difference was the service: Curtis (boat captain) and Edward (driver). They were so warm, attentive, and personable during our stay - it really made a difference. 10/10 recommend the Pridwin and definitely ask for Curtis and Edward!”

4.2 Good145 Reviews

“I had a wonderful experience at the Bridgehampton Inn & Restaurant! The food was absolutely outstanding—beautifully presented, fresh, and full of flavor and the service from our server was warm & attentive. The ambiance is charming and cozy, with that classic Hamptons elegance that makes you want to linger over dessert. We were honestly surprised that we haven't been here all these years—it's truly a gem that deserves all the praise it gets. The only small downside was the maitre d', who came across a bit less welcoming than the rest of the team. Thankfully, the rest of the staff more than made up for it with their friendliness and professionalism. Overall, we loved our evening and can't wait to return!”

4.7 Superb233 Reviews

“Wonderful property- rooms are large and clean and lovely. They have thought of everything- small amenities that make a difference. Cold filtered water provided in the room and around the property. Beach tote bag with towels provided in the room. Extra towels at the beach front. Beach lounge chairs with attached shade. Robes/slippers. Universal chargers beside. The staff is terrific- friendly and easy and knowledgeable. Dave provided dinner recommendations, was attentive- comped us a glass of wine when we had to wait a bit for our room. Absolutely recommend and will definitely return.”

4.9 Superb81 Reviews

“Stayed for a long weekend break. It was great. Very peaceful with an excellent host, lovely room, wonderful breakfast and a gorgeous dog called Peaches who we loved spending time with. Can fully understand why they have many repeat visitors, we will certainly be backRooms: Well appointed, plenty of towels etc.”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“The staff, service and food were absolutely on point.... oysters Rockefeller, the bone marrow and the lamb chops were a favorite among all our guests... Truly an amazing experience all the way around.... highly recommend the restaurant at the American Hotel in Sag Harbor.”

4.3 Superb256 Reviews

“Gorgeous accommodations. So pretty, clean, nice pool and seating area. Complimentary coffee station in lobby (with actual good coffee!). Friendly staff! Loved it! Highly recommend staying here.”

4.7 Superb63 Reviews

“My husband and I stayed at the Tapestry House for a wedding weekend in September. It was a truly wonderful and unique visit. The inn is beautiful–furnishings and details are perfect. Breakfasts were delicious and plentiful. Joan made us feel so welcomed. It was a memorable stay, and we hope to return!”

4.8 Superb21 Reviews

“Gorgeous little hotel, fantastic service, and a great area in Greenport! Felecia at the front desk is amazing. We loved raiding the galley late night and how most restaurants/bars were in walking distance. Visit Goldbergs in the AM for breakfast. Ten out of ten!”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“we come by boat every year by boat for a couple of nights location is fabulous. Property is beautiful staffing owners very accommodating. Our bonus was concert on the lawn right behind our boat on Tuesday night. We had a wonderful time as always highly recommended.”

3.7 Good56 Reviews

“I stopped by the Harbor Front to meet a friend for a drink. Wow, the lobby is beautiful. The design and the colours used are elegant but still fresh and inviting, accenting the really lovely details of the bar and the fireplace. This place definitely ups the game on Front Street.”

3.7 Good71 Reviews

“my wife and I try to stay at the Blue Inn every July for abour six or seven nights. Housekeeping is excellent, grounds are well kept, pool is immaculate. Management always makes you feel at home and welcome. Try it and you will return.”

2.2 Poor55 Reviews

“The staff here go above and beyond to cater to their guests. The staff makes you feel like family and it’s a special place. The rooms are spacious and well thought out and very conveniently located. I can’t wait to stay here again.”

3.6 Good76 Reviews