Jewelry Stores near Reynoldsburg, OH

30 locations found near Reynoldsburg
View Map

“I've had several pieces repaired here. They have always been nice to me. My husband has had a very expensive watch repaired. I've had my ring re sized. Prices are not unreasonable. They have become my jewelry repair place of choice. I even have a bracelet I can't take off. The jeweler literally takes it off cleans it and puts it back on for me.”

4.3 Superb7 Reviews

“I accidentally left my rings in homemade cleaner overnight which caused my yellow gold wedding band to turn reddish burgundy. The jeweler was so caring and kind. He restored it to its beautiful original color in just a few minutes. It looks brand new! You totally blessed me. Thank you so very much!!!”

4.9 Superb56 Reviews

“Super friendly and an excellent selection of items! Heidi was awesome and responsive to my weird requests and put together a great gift basket for me so quickly. I will definitely be ordering from here again!”

4.9 Superb50 Reviews

“Jeanie & all of the employees at Edward Warren were fantastic when searching for and finally creating my own wedding band using my mothers diamonds. Jeanie also helped us create a necklace for my mother and helped us find my husbands wedding band. They were kind, thorough and so knowledgeable! We will definitely be back to them for any of our jewelry needs.”

4.9 Superb44 Reviews

“Shopping for an engagement ring can be a daunting process, but I found the experience at the Diamond Cellar to be fantastic. They know the diamond business, and it’s great to have such a long-standing business to rely on for a larger purchase. Ellen (the best in my opinion) was knowledgeable, friendly, and no pressure. My fiancée and I are extremely happy and we look forward to working with Diamond Cellar & Ellen in the future!”

4.9 Superb43 Reviews

“Was warmly greeted by Jay who shared a brief history of the business. Love the interior-- the gold skeleton spoke to me! Well, visually! Felt really welcome and like I was in the right place. BTW, my anklet was happy to be in the very capable hands of Mr. Bling King! The repair was completed while I waited. Nice job, Mr. Bling King! As I observed their luxurious selection of jewelry, I believe that, as Jay said...the sky is not the limit! Happy to support this black owned business, and will return.”

4.9 Superb25 Reviews

“Travis was amazing and helped us out so much! He was so genuine and kind! We went to multiple stores to find an engagement ring but found ourselves back at Kay’s just because of Travis’ lovely customer service! Thanks Travis! ”

4.6 Superb67 Reviews

“Terry Janis has unique, vibrant merchandise and I have loved her shop for over 25 years. She offers high quality products, always gives her customers a fair price and many of the pieces I have purchased whether it be jewelry, decor, kitchen items, I still use on a regular basis. Also there are always great gifts for everyone you know. She often has the most unique jewelry in the city. Something for everyone.”

4.8 Superb23 Reviews

“Infinity made me a custom wedding band from my fiancés family’s sentimental diamonds. I had no idea what I wanted and they went above and beyond to help me design the perfect ring. Kristin showed me models of what it would look like until it was perfect. Kristin is incredibly kind and made the whole process easy. Plus it was affordable! Thank you so much for all of your work! The ring is perfect.”

5 Superb14 Reviews

“If you want to sell here, be sure to research your values ahead of time. He offered me 250 for a gold coin that would be 300 or so in very worn out condition. When I told him that I know the melt value is 230 and I expect at least 350, he was quick to adjust the price. So do your homework and they’ll treat you fairly. Go in blind and you can expect they’ll take advantage of an opportunity.”

4.6 Superb34 Reviews

“Absolutely loved this store! The lady that helped us was awesome she made us feel like family. She helped me pick a souvenir for my son. Couldn't believe how reasonable the prices were. If I ever come back to Ohio I will be coming back here.”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“Dale was great. Our family had some gold coins sitting around and we decided to sell some. Great price and was extremely nice to our son who was fascinated. Worth the drive to come from UA.”

4.5 Superb26 Reviews

“This place is fantastic. They always have something new and great to pick out. If you want a lovely local gift (Bexley, Columbus, Capital U, Ohio, etc), they have it all. Great people working here to. So helpful.”

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

“I cannot say enough about the Jared employee, Jordan Davis. Jordan was extremely helpful every step of the way, when it came to picking out a new wedding ring for my wife. Jordans knowledge and patients through the process was unbelievable. I would recommend to anyone who is thinking of purchasing any type of new jewelry to stop in and see Jordan. You will have a great experience with Jordan helping you.”

4.5 Superb23 Reviews

“Brian and his associates were extremely helpful and patient while my wife and I were customizing her engagement ring. He was able to craft her exactly what she was looking for, and also gave us an incredible deal. I will not hesitate to go back to them for any future needs.”

4.7 Superb11 Reviews

“Needed some watch batteries replaced, so after doing some research, I decided to try out Main Jewelers. I was greeted promptly by a friendly older gentleman. I told him that I needed two batteries installed into my timepieces. He quoted me the price, which I believe was $10 total, but don't quote me on that. I thought I would have to leave the watches, but he told me he could have them done in a few minutes. Just as he promised, the watches were ready in about 5 minutes. I have already recommended this place to one of my employees. They have a new customer in me. Friendly, fast, and cheap! Customer Service 1-5=5! Value 1-5=5!”

4.5 Superb15 Reviews

“It’s located next to AMC cinemas entranceSurrounded by various stores (Amazon Style, Jeni’s ice cream ?, Mac cosmetics , Northface , Lego giraffe ?)Good place to view at night with Christmas/New Year decoration lightsSummer/Fall is good as well to do window shopping and walk aroundEnjoy shopping !!”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews

“Asia is amazing!!! I called from out of the area looking for three specific pieces of jewelry. She was very patient with me as we discussed the names and numbers of each piece. She placed me on a brief hold to check each. They didn’t have any in stock but I would definitely drive the almost two hours if they had because she was so so so AWESOME! Excellent customer service simply doesn’t exist these days so it was greatly appreciated ?”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“I’ve been going here for about 4 years… My first purchase was a 10K 30” gold rope chain then shortly after that I went and got the matching bracelet. Today I decided to get a cross pendant for my chain. Great guys and great jewelry wouldn’t dream of going anywhere else and of course they work with you on price as well.”

4.3 Superb26 Reviews

“I visited 3 different jewelers in a week looking to sell jewelry… Bryan was the first to take the time with me and give me different options… all that options that would not make him any money…I returned to customize jewelry I already had and work was done to my specs and in a timely manner…Bryan has won my continued business and I will always refer and send anyone his way…”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“I love this upscale boutique at Easton. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, the shop is clean and spacious and beautifully laid out. But the best part is the merchandise. A beautiful variety of styles. From fine jewelry to shoes to the perfect outfit. It’s like going through your rich aunts closet! Love it!”

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

“Really cool! I'd never heard of this; my granddaughter asked for a gift. Staff can custom make any product you want. I was able to get earrings with the set and stones she likes. Great service and prices!”

4.3 Superb11 Reviews

“Quality diamonds & jewelry with exceptionally knowledgeable & helpful associates. Bottled water &/or champagne available upon request. Makes shopping more fun ????”

4.2 Good21 Reviews

“I normally wait until I have been to a place 3 times before I review but…I went here last night and the FLAVORS…and CUSTOMER SERVICE! I came when it was about to close and they were still in serve mode! Going for round two right now!”

4.1 Good20 Reviews

“Always a great find. I bought not one not two but 3 beautiful dream catchers here. I live almost 2 hours away and I make the drive for this store. The staff were all friendly and the prices are very fair.”

4.1 Good17 Reviews

“I have been a huge fan and customer of Thirty-One since I first discovered it in 2007. All the products I have purchased over the years are still holding up. In 2020, I loved it so much I decided to join as a consultant. It is an incredible company and I’m so thankful to be part of it.”

4 Good21 Reviews

You May Also Like