Buffalo Exchange is a unique thrift shop with a ton of clothes and shoes everywhere, offering a lot of variety for different styles. The staff is consistently described as fantastic, friendly, and nice, with many customers highlighting zero bad experiences and helpful, knowledgeable service that creates a fun and memorable shopping experience. Customers appreciate the option to donate items for store cash credit, making it easy to switch out old clothes. However, opinions on pricing are mixed. Some find most items pretty pricey, noting that similar items can be found elsewhere for less, while others report finding unexpected gems and good deals. A strong recommendation is to call before visiting to ask what specific items, like denim, are currently being bought, as inventory needs change. Some customers feel the selling process has become greedy, with clothes not holding much value beyond the price tag. A few reviews also mention that the customer base can seem entitled. Despite some criticisms, many customers had an incredible experience, would highly recommend the location, and plan to return.
I brought my buffalo in to the store yesterday and I was kicked out. I am just a weary buffalo trader and this store sounded perfect, instead of meeting a comunity of other buffalo trading nomads i was met with a life long ban from the store. Very misleading name for a store.
March 2026
Best Buffalo Exchange ever! Great selection and excellent staff!
March 2026
I gave a four star for the reason that this store offers variety in terms of clothing and shoes. Like most thrift stores, all you need is patience and impulse to stumble on the most exclusive piece of clothing. Prices are fair.
