On Second Thought Consignment, established in 2004, is a highly regarded consignment shop located in Lynchburg, Virginia. It is known as the premier destination for women's clothing, accessories, home decor, and furniture. Customers appreciate the store's organization, efficiency, and friendly staff, who provide excellent service. The quality and variety of merchandise, including unique items and diverse styles, have impressed many shoppers.
The shop offers great prices and regularly features clearance items that attract repeat customers. While some consignment experiences have noted a selective process for items, shoppers remain loyal due to the store's exceptional offerings. The furniture consignment shop nearby also receives praise for its great prices and wide selection.
Overall, On Second Thought Consignment stands out for its welcoming atmosphere, professionalism, and a strong commitment to providing a satisfying shopping experience. Many customers recommend it as a top choice for both shopping and consigning, making it a vital part of the local retail landscape.
High quality consignment. Very clean and great selections.
August 2026
Hands down best place to shop in town!!! I stop in everyday on my lunch break to shop. Staff is so friendly and helpful. I love seeing Charlotte sitting in her chair, watching people shop. Love this place!!!
July 2026
Second thought by far is the best consignment store you will find within miles of here. There is such a variety of items on both the furniture and clothing side. The girls that work there are super sweet and helpful. Love this store. If you can't find something here you're not looking hard enough.
