Thrift Stores near Menomonee Falls, WI

16 locations found near Menomonee Falls
View Map

“Always manage to find something. Did not realize until I got home that I was charged $10 instead of $1.99. Called and they were instantly able to confirm this and can go back for refund.”

2.6 Average35 Reviews

“I love this store!! Me and my friend went in today- the store owner lady was so helpful and sweet, she showed us around the store, the sizes for things, and prices. speaking of prices, everything was super affordable, i got a pair of super cute heels for 3$, a lace blouse for 3$, and a purse for 3$! everything was so cute and the store was well organized, clean, and it felt like a very nice place to be. definitely recommend going! :)”

5 Superb60 Reviews

“great store , always find something there at a great price !! and today they had a pop up food bank! ( Tuesday and Friday 1:00) they gave out alot of great food including frozen pizzas thank you Super Thrift you all are a true blessing !!”

4.6 Superb65 Reviews

“This is a small store, but every time I'm in here, I find something that I actually need for either myself or my house. The merchandise is usually of higher quality than the big-name thrift stores. FYI... it's cash only.”

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

“Stopped in randomly and was warmly greeted with smiles! Staff was very helpful and kind. Got this beautiful antique for a very fair price. Really cool little spot, will definitely be back!”

4.9 Superb16 Reviews

“The most organized and clean ReStore we've ever visited, with a wide variety of product categories and choices available. Good use of signage and labels/pricing.”

4.3 Superb75 Reviews

“Recently discovered this resale shop and I'm so happy i did. We went when they had the red tag bag sale. Meaning that all red tag items you can fit into the bag will only cost $1. We scored some amazing deals and the shoes were no more than $6. What a great store will be returning.”

4.4 Superb35 Reviews

“Lots of items up for grabs for those in need. The thrift shop has been a life saver for me when I was new here and it still it! Everyone is very cordial and helpful!?”

4.1 Good23 Reviews

“This thrift store is a fave of mine when shopping around for little trinkets. They have a surprisingly large selection of handkerchiefs which you really just don't see much of anymore. The items that are considered vintage are in a separate section and although they are priced a little higher do sometimes go down based on whatever deals may be going on that day/week. I stumbled upon it when driving by one day but have made it a point to stop in if I'm in the area, would definitely recommend checking them out if you're on the hunt for bits and bobbles!”

4 Good14 Reviews

“Huge selection of items and they take time to keep everything well organized even with "messy" customers! Today's visit was disappointing as the shelves were messy and many clothing items should be salvaged and not put out for sale.”

3.9 Good91 Reviews

“The Donations guy was great and most helpful. Other store staff seem so tired.It is becoming more difficult to shop here for several reasons… These stores are about as disorganized as they have always been (stacking heaps of items the smallest space available).Please don’t get me wrong because their mission seems solid and unwavering but their focus on… let’s say … selling a name brand pair of shoes which the tread is half worn out for $15 or $20 is not cool.”

3.8 Good28 Reviews

“I love this wonderful store! Cool and classy merchandise, exquisitely arranged, at very reasonable prices. The staff are always friendly & helpful. Always seems to be a fun deal- yesterday it was 50% off men’s & women’s clothes to honor Veterans Day.”

3.7 Good21 Reviews

“Lots of stuff here, some of the prices are a bit much but they do have cheaper stuff too I'd say most things are priced fairly. The old man who tested the ceiling lamp is very nice”

3.5 Good29 Reviews

“The work force experience was easy and fast..Also want to give a big thanks to Jay She help me wrap up a situation I had with unemploymentThat made my day!!I Thank JAY for all the help 5 stars to you”

3.6 Good46 Reviews

“I don't visit this Goodwill location often, but when I do I always leave with some good finds! It's located off the expressway near several other big box chains, but tucked away down a winding road. The items were well organized and shelves had plenty to look through. The pricing was also very fair compared to other stores.”

2.6 Average27 Reviews

“My son is 4 and I feel like a fool for never thinking of this store. Definitely consider coming here before buying outerwear, baby items and especially toys! Doll houses and higher priced toys that are usually over $150 were $25. They keep a very clean place for how much merch they have. Everyone was also very friendly when checking out . Will definitely be back.”

3.3 Good126 Reviews