Auto Insurance near Middleton, WI

15 locations found near Middleton
View Map

“Well Mr. Donnelly has been taking care of my Car and Rv now for years and been very Happy. Great rates and Customer service from Michael and All state has been fantastic. Happy Customer . Thanks Guys.”

4.9 Superb26 Reviews

“I had to make a few adjustments to my auto policy. My request took place during the holiday season. Therefore, I expected a response within a week's time. To my surprise, I received a telephone call from Mariah Sherry at 6:15 p.m. - well after the end of the work day. She was very kind and helpful. Her subsequent follow up demonstrated her penchant of detail and customer service. Thank you, Cliff Insurance Agency and Mariah!”

4.9 Superb124 Reviews

“Noah and Natalie helped me out with a new quote. I got a lower rate, more insurance benefits and lowered my deductible!Very professional and kind costumer service. Thank you!”

5 Superb40 Reviews

“The entire office was professional,welcoming,and very much on top of their game. Tristan was attentive,kind,and helpful in all ways you want in your agent. Jordan,the owner,went out of his way to be accommodating. Rates were very competitive. Best insurance experience,by far!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“I am so happy with my State Farm Insurance Agency! After I was in a DVC (deer vehicle crash) I was devastated that it happened, but also because they said my car would be totaled (all my airbags deployed). Ann Oradei helped me with all my questions and troubles and got me through the claims process. She is awesome and I couldn't have gotten through this without someone like her. She really cares about people. Thank you, Ann, you're an angel!”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“We’ve been long time American Family customers. We have always had wonderful service with Am Fam. We enjoyed our insurance review time today with Kailey. What a delightful and wonderful addition to your office family. She did a great job! Enjoyed finally meeting you Vincent, as well. You can’t go wrong with this agency. They will take care of all your insurance needs.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“Matty and the team at American Family were awesome after my auto accident. I was kept informed on what came next and moved smoothly thru a scary and inconvenient experience.”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“I have been doing business with Patrick for almost 3 decades. His warm and caring attitude along with attention to every detail result in a fantastic organization that can handle any type of insurance need. There have been times when I have carried certain insurance policies with other providers, however I always returned to Patrick and his very responsive team. This office currently supports me with business, home, auto and life insurance with some of the most competitive rates in the area. I invite you to give them the opportunity to earn your business. Thank you for the wonderful service Patrick Marsden State Farm!”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“Not sure why there are so many reviews about poor customer service. I’ve been with Susan and her team for a couple of years and so far things have been great! Sure they raise the prices, but what insurance company doesn’t?? I’ve got my home and auto through them and will continue to be a loyal customer.”

4.7 Superb36 Reviews

“Mike listened well, found solutions to what I needed, and has provided consistent and timely responses to my follow-up questions and ongoing needs. Top shelf service.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Michael is a top-notch insurance agent. He and his team have taken good care of my family for years. My experience with Michael has been consistently positive: he is easy to talk to, available for questions or needs, and strong and sharp in those rare instances when something comes up that requires attention. I've appreciated his skill at checking in - just the right amount, and making me aware of my coverage and other opportunities - without being pushy. I consider him what I most want in an insurance agent: someone who I know has my back.”

4.6 Superb10 Reviews

“I am writing mainly to counter the unbelievable negative reviews here. We have used Curtis Agency for over 15 years and are very happy with their service. Contrary to the stuff written in two other reviews, Martin and Kim are very prompt to return calls, to followup on insurance claims, suggest alternate insurance companies to get you the best premiums, and even help with finding contractors for home improvement.”

3.7 Good3 Reviews

“Just wish it was easier to get the more competitive rates rather than having to call and drum up the competition myself. Otherwise very happy customer in terms of the service and ultimately the value we were able to achieve.”

4.2 Good45 Reviews

“I was looking to switch insurance companies to one that fit my lifestyle and worked will with my small business. My rep has always been helpfulness, timely and straightforward with any requests I've had. I've recommended Rural Mutual to many of my small business friends.”

3.8 Good22 Reviews