Jewelry Stores in Middleton, WI

7 locations found near Middleton
View Map

“I am not one who is known for being brief…I came into Middleton Jewelers, needing some repairs to a family heirloom. The work Logan crafted was far beyond my expectations!!!! I am happy to say I walked out with a few unexpected pieces at incredible prices, I couldn’t walk away from. A pair of earrings like you will never see again. To a ring that hopefully officiates & unites me to a man I hope to grow old with!!! I cannot be more grateful to these kind gentleman. I only hope you will consider Middleton Jewelers, when looking for value and go away with a piece of mind and beautiful jewelry to match. ?”

4.9 Superb142 Reviews

“This is a family owned business, and I have to say, they made me feel like part of the family. Time was lost just chatting and sharing about our lives. What a connection. What personal care. I look forward to going back and I cannot recommend them enough! Oh, and very knowledgeable!! A great place!”

4.9 Superb110 Reviews

“I had some coins that I wanted to liquidate and I have had extremely good luck based mainly on Google reviews during the last few years. Between all the five star reviews and the fact these guys are associated or members of the Professional Coin Grading Service was enough for me to contact them. Josh was amazingly knowledgeable and patient with all my questions. I had an appointment in Madison today so I gave him a call and arranged a visit. Josh was just as amazing in person as he seemed on the phone. I'm very happy with the transaction and I hope he is too. I wouldn't hesitate for a minute to give them a call. Thank you guys !!”

4.9 Superb32 Reviews

“I have been purchasing custom jewelry from John/Christine Designs over the last 18 or 19 years. When I need to find something extra special with outstanding attention to design and craftsmanship, John/Christine Designs has never failed to have that special piece or the ability to create that special piece including custom matching of stones for pendants, earrings and rings. Their gemstone collection is exquisite and John's craftsmanship and design skill in executing custom mountings is phenomenal. If you need that special something and have not been able to find it at "ordinary" jewelry stores, please contact them and let them know what you are looking for. They are highly creative artists with a knack for finding or creating that special item. Unequivocally recommended! They also have a talent for creating new custom work around that special stone that may be in an outdated setting!!”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“Jeff was incredibly helpful in finding an engagement ring within my budget. I speak very highly of this place and love that it's local and not big box brand.”

4.7 Superb34 Reviews

“I'm very sad that there's another women's clothing store in Greenway Station closing its doors. First there was Coldwater Creek, then Christopher and Banks, and now Soft Surroundings. I'm giving 5 stars for the store, the merchandise, and the associates. Zero stars because it's going out of business.”

4.6 Superb31 Reviews

“Wife and I brought in a bunch of stuff (coins, silver, silver plated items) to be evaluated. Jason was very patient and honest with us, there was a lot to go through. I would definitely recommend them.”

4.3 Superb80 Reviews