Shoe Stores in Sun Prairie, WI

“Girlfriend took me here to have my feet analyzed as I have had a lot of problems with my feet and knees. Super impressed with the process and Noah! The best experience I have ever had in getting new shoes! Oh and by the way, their price on Hoka’s beat Amazon by $75!”

“I called ahead to check if a pair of Black Iron Red Wings (forget the exact model name) was in stock, and they confirmed they had it. I came in about 30 minutes later, and everything went very smoothly. The staff member working—unfortunately, I didn’t catch his name—was professional, quick, and helpful.

The customer service was excellent, and the entire process was easy from start to finish. The boots themselves are fantastic—great craftsmanship and comfort that will only get better as they break in. I’ve only had them for a day, but I can already tell they’re going to be perfect.

Whoever helped me today (October 13, 2025) — thank you! I really appreciate your time and great customer service.”

“My husband purchased his Good Feet insoles 21 years ago, He had instant relief when wearing them. Knee pain that he had been dealing with for many years was gone. He was able to start running. Last year he ran the Boston Marathon. He ran the marathon with the same insoles he purchased 21 years ago. After running many marathons and daily use, the insoles had worn out.
We were told when we purchased them 21 years ago that they had a lifetime warranty. We called the Middleton Good Feet store and set up an appointment. We went to the appointment and they informed us that we would get a brand new set of insoles for free.
We were very happy with the service and the new insoles fit perfectly. Randy states “he couldn’t live without them”. Great company!
Highly recommended!”