Yoder's Fresh Market is a friendly, pleasant place in Sarasota offering a relaxing experience. It is an awesome little market with an abundance of products. Customers find fresh produce, baked goods, and a good variety of homemade prepared foods. This includes items like chicken salad, tuna fish salad, soups, sandwiches made to order, refrigerated breakfast sandwiches, jams, breads, desserts, candies, cookies, and memorabilia. The food is delicious, tastes great, and the portions are large. Everything is made fresh and has never disappointed. The staff are always kind, pleasant, friendly, and helpful. It's a perfect place to stop after work or when passing through to get a home-cooked meal to go, pick up goodies, and stock up. A tip is to check the cooler in the very back for marked-down items.
Great grab and go options from the restaurant. He place to pick up the very popular pot pies. Other grab-and-go items as well including fresh cookies and desserts.
February 2026
The fresh made wraps and chicken salad croissant are amazing. If you ever want a deli sandwich in Sarasota go to Yoder's Market. I'm always scratching my head how they take simple ingredients and make them taste so much better than if I'd made it at home. Love the turkey cheddar wrap with ranch.
February 2026
We found all sorts of yummy treats and fresh bread, as well as Birch Beer, which tastes like a mixture of Dr. Pepper and Rootbeer. We bought cookies, pie, and their well known whoopie pie.
