Toy Stores near Hillsdale, NJ

28 locations found near Hillsdale

“The peak of game stores. Gotta review this like a Steam game.

Graphics (Atmosphere): Outstanding
Pricing: Almost always on-par with PriceCharting, if not better.
Variety: You would think it would be impossible to fit this much into a store the size of a classroom. They have everything from games, consoles, accessories, cables, batteries, controllers, plushies, hats, toys, board games, figures, candy, stickers, trading cards, and even Hatsune Miku Potato Head.

Overall Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If you're in the area, this is a must see store

*thank you john gamezone*”

4.8 Superb186 Reviews

“This is a place where all your nerdy, anime loving dreams come true. Staff is very nice and helpful all the time. Overall a great place to shop for your nerdy/geeky crafty needs.”

5 Superb108 Reviews

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely amazing experience at Build-A-Bear! Every single staff member was so kind, patient, and genuinely interested in making our visit special from start to finish. You can tell they truly care about creating memories, not just selling bears. The energy, smiles, and attention to detail made it such a worthwhile and fun experience — both for kids and adults! Highly recommend this location to anyone looking for great service and a heartwarming time. ??”

4.9 Superb93 Reviews

“Cruzin with RCs is a great little store & awesome track. This place has a little bit of everything. Ron & Steve are extremely helpful and knowledgeable. This place has 3 awesome tracks as well. Mini-Z, drift track, and a large astroturf off road track. Check this place out if you are in the market for a new RC car or place to race.”

5 Superb79 Reviews

“This store is 40-50 minutes out of my way,However I make the drive happen almost 3x a week regardless! And it’s all due to the amazing staff that works here as well as the customers.My first experience here I was shopping for a few kippah’s, browsing around. It was a lot to take in, since Tuvia’s is stocked with almost anything you can think of!I came back two more times, and on each time I’ve made a friend or two in the store while checking out.On my latest visit a customer paid for my items just because he could tell I was new to the area and he chose to be a kind gentleman that day.Overall the atmosphere of the store is very welcoming, the staff are helpful and friendly - ready to help you find whatever it is that you may need. Last but not least, the location although it is far from me, I do not mind because there’s a lot to do in the area, with Evergreen being up the road, and a Yeshiva as well off of College Rd, what else can you say?Perfect store, great customer service, high quality products that’ll last a lifetime and kind people all around. Every encounter I have here makes me proud to be a Jew in a world that makes it hard to be Jewish. Thanks for what you do , Tuvia’s may G-d bless your business!”

4.9 Superb75 Reviews

“I love that B&N is pet friendly. It's a great place to visit, browse for my next read, and take the fur-baby for a climate controlled walk through the aisles. If you or your dog get thirsty, you can stop at the Starbucks in the store for a drink and sit at the cafe tables or comfy chairs. My dog loved her pup-accino. Side note, taking a dog to such locations is also great for dog training, provided you hold the leash tight and remain aware of other dogs and people/children who may be fearful of dogs.”

4.5 Superb216 Reviews

“Just ordered chaise lounge outdoor tufted cushion replacement . It appears this is exactly what color and dimensions I want . Looking forward to receiving this order . Company has good offerings but a little more trouble to get through to placing order . Thanks !”

4.5 Superb110 Reviews

“I love Lego Star Wars I got the imperial star destroyer but I was a bit bum out that they was out of stock of the gingerbread AT-AT but the workers was very nice they help me got the Lego app and now next time I get a Lego set I get a $8.00 discount ☺️?”

4.6 Superb90 Reviews

“It is TONS OF TOYS! And it's much more organized than it appears at first glance. The staff is very willing to be helpful, but not at all pushy. They have anything retro or new that I was able to ponder while searching for gifts. The have gift wrapping at checkout, and are again, so helpful... I hope this helps you. Good call if you choose to go there.”

4.6 Superb86 Reviews

“Great place everything here is 5 dollars or under. Me and my friend went to buy here Halloween decorations a lot of options but it was easy to choose. Everything is well organized and many many things here”

4.4 Superb112 Reviews

“I love this store Open to 6 different locations.There are some items that you find in all of the stores but each store has different items Some cater to children some the home and pets the workout products have not been as good as they have in the past The gateway plaza has More of a selection. Haven't been there in a. while, So it may have changed. They used to have the candy from back in the day. I don't find it as much anymore.”

4.3 Superb132 Reviews

“I bought a pokemon card from Lolipop toy shop , and the quality was excellent ,and the price was very reasonable . The store is well organized and the staff were friendly, knowledgeable and helped me with finding the toy for me .
Moreover, there are variety of toys , so I recommend everyone to do visit lolipop toy shop to get your favorite toy.
Thank you Lolipop toy shop .”

4.5 Superb37 Reviews

“We Enjoy coming to this location of Lego store. They have so many different items displayed to see what they look like once they put together. They had a wonderful variety of Lego pens that I have been looking for. The staff is very friendly and helpful in finding what we needed. Also very organized and clean.”

4.3 Superb97 Reviews

“We were in town for a wedding. It was raining and I needed to keep my 2 1/2 year old grandson busy. I saw Tons of Toys was only a 10 minute drive away so we went. It was perfect. We spent about an hour in the store looking. The cashier lead us to the finger skateboards. He was so polite and patient with my grandson. We left with a pack of skateboards and a rubber snake. Fun times.”

4.8 Superb58 Reviews

“Just wanted to send a big thank you to your staff! I ordered the State fuzzy basketball backpack for my nephew literally 24 hours ago and he’s already received it. I was super disappointed that the State website wasn’t restocking it, but then I found it on your online store — and on sale at that! Your website said shipping is 7-9 days so I wasn’t expecting it to get there that quickly. A pleasant surprise and great customer service. And the bag is so adorable. Thanks again!”

4.5 Superb63 Reviews

“So happy to have discovered Benny's! The products were very well received by the participants at our Women's Seder (stencils used for painting Timbrels) and I found the quality to be excellent. Shipping was very fast and prices are quite fair. I’m glad I found Benny’s! I will definitely order again.”

4.7 Superb32 Reviews

“This place has usually expensive toys for lower prices. It's a great way to get out of production toys and rare toys you can't find elsewhere. There are also a few vehicles that fit with my model trains that are helpful. The only thing I don't like is that this mall doesn't enforce the mask wearing, so It's unsafe to visit at the present time.”

4.8 Superb37 Reviews

“Awesome place. Called ahead because I'm clueless about baby toys. She asked my budget, then put together a themed series of gifts within that budget. In and out in 15 minutes. I didn't explore around too much since I had a specific goal but I'll be back in the future. Wrapped the gift for free too!”

4.4 Superb38 Reviews

“I had a wonderful experience at Papillon Bambino! The woman who helped me was incredibly kind and knowledgeable, making the process of finding my daughter’s baptism dress so special and stress-free. The boutique has a beautiful selection of high-quality pieces, and the attention to detail is unmatched. I highly recommend this shop for anyone looking for elegant and timeless children’s clothing. I will definitely be returning for future special occasions!”

4.6 Superb18 Reviews

“This is an excellent store if you have children who have parties. They let you buy knickknacks by the piece for a very reasonable price. There are also some decent deals on toys albeit none of them are name brands that you have heard of. A box of knockoff Legos for $12 work as well as the real thing for about 1/4 of the price.”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“Hollywood Heros has two things going for it. 1) An amazing, incredible selection of toys, new and vintage. 2) The nicest owners possible. My 12 y.o. son is a huge Star Wars collector, and he discovered HH on Yelp about. year ago. We've gone maybe a dozen times now even though it's an hour round trip. We often find rare and impossible to get items here and if it's not on the shelves, it's probably in their basement, so just ask. We became friendly with Jordan and Val on our trips there, and Jordan has been especially gracious. He always has time to talk, answer questions, and be friendly. Even when we come to just window shop, we still have great talks. Recently my son was looking for an ARC-170 gunship, and Jordan and Val had just gotten one in that had missing parts, and they gave it to my son as a thank you for being a loyal customer. It made my son's month. The store is a block from the central shopping district, so when we go we get bagels or Korean chicken and make a day out of it, or go the few blocks to Trader Joes. I know a Trader Joes isn't a selling point for a store specifically, but as a parent of someone who loves shopping here it's nice to have a cute town that can be part of the experience.”

4.5 Superb28 Reviews

“I love this store, great selection of accesories, clothing, greeting cards and hodgepodge of items. I had a problem with using a coupon on my phone, the manager promptly resolved it. The store is a little pricey but if you register online they send you different coupons.”

4.1 Good29 Reviews

“New owners seem to know what’s trending these days! My son LOVES the pokemon cards here, especially the Japanese ones. He’s been getting some good pulls from this store’s selection. Will be coming back again!”

4.2 Good42 Reviews

“Cool place to take the kids if it’s raining , but your going to spend a ton on a bear your kids will want every accessory on earth. But their smiles st thr end makes it worth it. Could be in a better locationn”

3.9 Good62 Reviews

“Purple Bow to the rescue!!! I needed a baby gift in a pinch on my way to the airport and Ahuva from Purple Bow made it happen. She was able to have a baby towel personalized beautifully within 15 minutes. They have the best customer service and products!!”

3.9 Good13 Reviews

“Very nice store with Reasonable prices and always packed with stuff and I went there once and I won 500$ after buying my first lottery ticket and it is very lucky store for me. The employers working there are very friendly”

3.9 Good23 Reviews

“They have a great selection! Would recommend looking for any and everything here! They are great with finding specific party items. Most of the prices are fair not the cheapest but great quality”

3.6 Good96 Reviews

“Good crowd of gamers in the back room... Not sure what games they were playing but looks like Warhammer and various card collectors games like Pokémon... The front shop is nicely layed out with mostly collectables...”

3.6 Good158 Reviews