Hotels near Gardiner, NY

“Just back from this lovely lodge. Great setting, welcoming people, great room, awesome breakfast…
We actually had a very poor night as people had a party in the room nextdoor (I asked them at 1 am to tone down but they sent me away…). I didn’t dress up and ask the hotel to do something but I wish the person on the frontdesk would keep an eye on this passed a certain time. Can’t blame the hotel though. Disrespectful people are the problem.
I’ll come back for sure ?.

Edited:

I came back for 2 night in August 25. Still an awesome place but I confirm there’s an acoustic problem. We could hear all the noise from the surrounding rooms. We were lucky nobody was much talking or watching a movie till late but we could hear everything, steps etc… take your earplugs.”

“I went here for a school trip and it was beautiful, I did the bb gun range, I did it before so I didnt wait for the instructions, almost got kicked out, the lazer tag was fun, but it smelt bad in a specific corner. The poll was small but good, its well priced for ice cream and stuff and overall it was a really good trip, but the restaurant inside needs more meat.”

“I will just start by saying... if you take anything away from this review it is to book one of Audrey's outstanding properties for your wedding/gathering/celebration of any kind! My husband and I got married at Audrey's Old Mill location on 8/24/24 and it made for the perfect setting for our celebration. What sets Audrey's apart from other venues is that is doesn't feel like a venue. In the absolute best way possible. What drew me to Old Mill, aside from it being an incredibly beautiful property, was that it is a place to gather. We were able to host 50 of our friends and family on-site for our wedding weekend, and some of my favorite memories from the weekend came from everyone naturally gathering on the deck of the Farmhouse after the rehearsal dinner and after the night of the wedding. There is really no better feeling than hanging out with your favorite people, all in one place, laughing, sharing a drink, and reminiscing. It was surreal.

Booking Audrey's Old Mill for our wedding was the best decision we made. The property/rooms are absolutely stunning. It is charming and cozy, yet incredibly refined, and the perfect environment to make you feel at ease leading up to your wedding. The food, oh my gosh, the food. I could go on and on about the food, and so did my guests because one thing we heard most about from guests was how incredible and plentiful the food was! And I can't forget to mention the drinks; their cocktails were so delicious and refreshing. House-made thyme lemonade? House-made lavender agave simple syrup? Say. No. More. The staff... incredible. I will never forget the moment before walking down the aisle, one of the incredible team members from Old Mill handing me a glass of water and holding up the train of my dress until the moment I began walking. I felt so comfortable and taken care. I know that my friends and family will never forget that the team at Old Mill acknowledged everyone by their first name. They are simply the best. And TOM! A moment for Tom, who was our buddy for the day. He was so attentive. Immediately after the ceremony he introduced himself, gave us every cocktail to try, asked us which one was our favorite, and proceeded to make sure our glasses were never empty of our favorite cocktail for the rest of the night. Beyond that, he was constantly checking in, seeing if we needed anything, and provided frequent/memorable comic relief.

All of this to say, thank you to every single person at Audrey's Old Mill that made our celebration so special. We were blown away, our friends and family were blown away, and we will forever be grateful to their outstanding team that made the day so special. We will definitely be back, and we can't wait!”

“Our room was huge! For 2 adults and 3 children we had tons of space. The rooms were very clean, the beds are comfortable with excellent pillows & linens. The staff were lovely and accommodating. Breakfast was small but fresh. The coffee wasn't the best and I couldn't figure out how to work the in room nespresso. The bar was fantastic with amazing drinks. My children loved the game room.”

“We found this hidden gem for our first wedding anniversary in 2016 and have been coming back ever since (now with two kids). Each time it gets better and better. Maria and Joe are divinely chill — think of your favorite cool Aunt and Uncle. The accommodations are exquisitely comfy and chic and Maria’s breakfasts are to kill for (no joke — try to get in between me and my plate at your own risk ?)... on a scale of 1 to 5, Mountain Meadows is at least a 7.5…”

“What a gorgeous place. The state is sprawling and has wonderful hikes as well as a lake that offers beautiful views while kayaking, paddling and canoeing. The rooms are small but well appointed, most with balconies overlooking the lake and a fireplace. Fall is the busiest time for the resort as it beings people from all over the world coming for the changing leaves. Great memories!”

“Staff is wonderful, the rooms are clean and comfortable. A quiet environment that felt safe. Not a 5 Star luxury stay, but if you're looking for a warm, clean friendly environment, with a staff that clearly takes pride in their establishment at a really good price?, I highly recommend this lovely little hotel.. Gail is a treasure, making us feel welcome and cared for. The staff checked on us to insure that we had all needed supplies after our first night. What a pleasant experience, thank you to all who made our 3 day visit so wonderful!!”

“The rooms in the facility were clean and comfortable. It met all of my needs for a quick place to stay. The staff was friendly and helpful. Recommended.

Rooms: A standard hotel room but well equipped, everything worked, nice showers.”