Screaming Mimi's Vintage is a well-known and beloved store in New York City, recognized for its wide selection of vintage and costume pieces. It is a popular destination for those seeking unique, one-of-a-kind items, whether for fashion, costumes, or themed parties. The shop offers a curated collection of vintage clothing, jewelry, eyewear, and couture pieces that span decades, with organized racks categorized by themes such as "20s" or "Y2K." Customers often find helpful, knowledgeable staff who assist in selecting the perfect items, making shopping a pleasant experience. The store is especially appreciated for its theatrical costumes, including second-hand theater costumes, masks, wigs, and accessories suitable for Halloween or themed events. Prices vary, with some rare or designer items costing more, but many pieces are reasonably priced. Visitors have enjoyed the lively, creative energy of special events like vintage doll sales and holiday gatherings, which add to the store’s vibrant atmosphere. The store is praised for its stylish presentation and friendly environment, making it a must-visit for residents and tourists alike. While primarily focused on costume and theatrical pieces, Screaming Mimi's is also a go-to spot for vintage fashion lovers seeking distinctive, quality items in a fun, well-organized setting.
Walked in and had no idea what i wanted to wear for Purim and the staff were so sweet and helpful
Walked out with a full costume
Stores been around for a while so happy to support a NYC staple
January 2026
best place to shop for halloween or a themed party!
November 2025
One of the best laid out vintage stores. Have all sorta cool artsy pieces from the last hundred years! The owner, Dani, is very friendly and cool too! Def come here to explore your creative side
