Grocery Stores in Sag Harbor, NY

4 locations found near Sag Harbor
View Map

“Well I went here to get some fill in foods such gf breads, crackers, tea, coffee, and juice. The store is labeled well with the products in each isle. The store is clean free of odors hazardous materials”

4.2 Good90 Reviews

“The Noyack is their tuna melt- get it on a baguette. Great GREAT bread here. I ordered a meaty sandwich (Italian I think) and it wasn't great. So choose your sandwich wisely. I look forward to coming back for their Cuban sandwich. Great breakfast options too!!”

4.1 Good80 Reviews

“Convenient small grocer nestled in a residential area close to Long Beach, Noyak, and Sag Harbor. Fresh produce, good deli counter with prepared dishes as well. Offers customers pantry staples and baked goods too.”

3.9 Good94 Reviews

“Stayed in Sag Harbor for a week back in May and shopped here quite a few times since it was so close. High prices are to be expected in the Hamptons but the selection was great and the staff were helpful and much more polite than those at the other grocer a few doors down.”

3.7 Good55 Reviews