Grocery Stores in Shelter Island, NY

“This is such a funny/lovely little grocery.It reminded me of the small town grocery store from the 2007 flop, "The Mist." It also has shockingly good music playing throughout the store. I found myself dancing several times in the aisles only to catch of a glimpse of several other shoppers doing the same. What a riot!”

“Diane was unbelievable – I called her right as the store was closing from Sunset Beach begging for fire Wood and she agreed to stay late for me and she did even though I got there later than anticipated and also helped me find a few other things I might like such as s’more’s”

“We so enjoy this little gem of a market!!! Marie has the highest quality of food of any place on shelter Island, and probably the East End. We ride from Sag Harbor on our bikes at least once a week for a latte and an egg sandwich. Nobody else makes an egg sandwich anything close to hers. She has the highest standard for quality all organic eggs and even in her latte she uses organic milk which no one else does. Marie is one of the hardest working people in the Hamptons! She has clothing, stores, furniture, stores in SHELTER ISLAND, Montauk, Greenport, and she had one in Sag Harbor that burnt down in the theater fire. I don't know where she gets her energy. She has a lovely staff that works like a well oiled machine! People come in and out by the droves without a long wait. Her back garden/ patio overlooks the SHELTER ISLAND yacht club . You can sit there with your latte and enjoy a magnificent view on the water, one of the few places that has outdoor dining on the water. We treasure this beautiful bistro.!!! Thank you Marie!!!”