Pilgrim Surf + Supply is a unique and captivating shopping experience in Brooklyn. The store offers an impressive selection of high-quality brands, each carefully curated by the knowledgeable and friendly staff. From the moment you step inside, the welcoming atmosphere and thoughtful layout make it easy to find what you're looking for, whether it's surf-specific gear or timeless fashion pieces.
The store has a distinct personality, with a human and personal vibe that sets it apart from typical retail experiences. Customers praise the store's attention to detail, from the impeccable presentation to the carefully selected music that creates a relaxing ambiance. The owner, Chris, is described as an extremely personable and hospitable individual with a wealth of knowledge about culture, art, music, and surfing.
While the prices may be higher than some other retailers, many customers find the quality and craftsmanship of the products to be well worth the investment. The store's presence on the New York surf scene has helped to put the city more firmly on the map, offering a unique and authentic shopping experience that caters to both surf enthusiasts and fashion-conscious consumers.
Overall, Pilgrim Surf + Supply is a gem in the Brooklyn retail landscape, offering a refreshing and peaceful shopping experience that celebrates the intersection of culture, art, and the surf lifestyle.
Spin art was never ready for the curatorial level of this space. Take a record in the collection for a spin.
April 2026
This store is such a vibe. Right when you walk in you can’t help but take in how high the ceilings are. Found some really cute pieces in here. The set up they have in the back corner to play vinyls was pretty cool.
March 2026
used to be lovely to shop here - they still have great stuff but the staff they have now are comically unfriendly / don't know how to make people feel welcome
