Buffalo Exchange is a popular secondhand clothing store known for its stylish and affordable offerings. The Penn store location has a celebratory and great vibe, with the staff being described as lovely and helpful, particularly an employee named Sam. While customers can find unique items they love, the selection can be hit-or-miss, and the pricing of certain fast fashion brands is considered unreasonable. Some customers have had negative experiences when trying to sell items back to the store, with concerns over the store's memory and transparency. Overall, Buffalo Exchange is a mixed bag - it offers a fun shopping experience with a friendly staff, but the pricing and inventory can be inconsistent. Customers are advised to manage their expectations and compare prices when selling items back to the store.
Staff were very attentive and helpful at this location. The store is organized and clean and easy to shop. There is a mix of fast fashion brands and some high-end brands although not a huge selection.Lots of unique pieces. Worth taking the time to really peruse through the racks, I found a few hidden gems!
May 2026
I had one of the best shopping experiences I’ve had in a long time! The staff were so kind and personable! They hung up my clothing options when my hands got full on multiple occasions. Great inventory and fairly responsible pricing for the items
April 2026
I was was referred by a friend of mines nickky I love the store and all the items will come again !! 🤍
