“Epic spot! Huge selection of main brands & tons of local flair. Super helpful staff, I wanted a specific deck for X-Mas & they reached out immediately once it was back in stock.”
“I've been on a hunt for a pair of cute, comfortable silver heels for my friend's wedding (and you know how hard it can be to find comfortable silver heels that aren't costume-y or cute silver heels that are actually comfortable). Online, I saw this location had the cutest pair w/ pillow walk cushions in my size. So, I called this location and spoke with Angel and he was more than happy to put an 8 and 8.5 to the side for me to try on in-store. Walking in, I saw this store is so conveniently located and has a gorgeous selection of shoes and purses!! I was able to try on both pairs with ease and get my right size. I mentioned that it felt a lil tight around my pinky toe. I was able to buy my shoes and have them stretched overnight and ready for pick-up at 5:30. The next day, I came early around 2:30, and my shoes were already ready! And they felt PERFECT! Angel was so attentive without being overbearing! And the other staff there were so kind too! Love this store and the staff; I will definitely be back!”
“I’ve come here for many years and they, by far, have the best shoe selection in all of Milwaukee! The vintage and streetwear is a bonus, and the guys are always willing to help style me. Will be back regularly, highly recommend.”
“5 stars for Lilly M! She was a stellar salesperson who lifted my spirits and self-confidence on a day when I wasn't feeling or looking particularly cute. I was so impressed by her genuine desire to understand my personal style and her determination to find me something that I would like, all while being funny and keeping things light. I was a tough customer to please, style-wise, but she went above and beyond to ensure I had a positive experience.
It was one of the best, most authentic experiences that I have had with a salesperson in a very long time. Lilly's a star.”
“Such a fun store! There was so much to choose from that I didn’t even know where to start. Everyone was super helpful and I’ll definitely be back. Shoutout to Mari as well!! 💜🩷💚”
“The cashier Emma at Nordstrom rack Wauwatosa WI, did an amazing job. She nicely folded all my clothing, as well as informed me about all the benefits of getting a Nordstrom credit card. I immediately applied for the credit card with the professional help from Emma. I was approved and was able to use the 5 percent off my transaction and received a 40 dollar discount on my next purchase. It was a triple win for me. 1. The excellent customer service from Emma 2. A 5 percent off my transaction. 3. 40 dollars off my next purchase. Emma made my day”
“I am in love with this store. So many deals specially on weekend. If you are lucky you get new collection at best prices. Best place for shopping office cloths, skin care, fitness cloths, men’s wear, shoes and kids dresses. Great perfume collection.”
“Oni is amazing! I had called a hour before this store even opened and she actually answered the phone! Which NEVER happens with retail stores. I asked a bunch of questions and she did her best to answer them all but some she wasn't sure of, then about a hour later when she got the answers she found my number to call me back and I never even asked her to do this, she did this herself and I can't not believe the amazing customer service she provided! Thank you so much! Definitely an amazing worker!”
“I came in a few weeks ago to get some new shoes and had the BEST service ever. Kwan helped me out, and I will always go back to this location specifically for them! They were patient, helpful and solution focused when what I wanted wasn't in stock. I went to Journey's in Southridge a few days ago and since having a 5 star customer service experience with Kwan, this didn't even compare. To be honest, the Southridge people didn't even get off their stools behind the counter to greet me. Mayfair is a farther drive for me but one I am willing to make for the level of service I received! They definitely need a raise and a big pat on the back! Thanks Kwan, you're the best!”
10AM - 8PM
2500 N Mayfair Rd Ste 30, Wauwatosa
Shoe Stores
“Stopped in to return a dress I bought at the Hilldale location. The process was a breeze! It literally took 30 seconds. The girl who helped me was very nice. There was no judgement or questioning on her end. I also did not feel pressured to buy anything as I looked in the store afterwards. I prefer this location over Madison.”
“I wish there were more Ann Taylors in the area - this is really the only one in greater Milwaukee and it’s one of my favorite shops.
Every time I come in, I feel welcomed by the staff. They aren’t overly friendly and give you plenty of space to shop at leisure, but are very available to offer and provide help if needed. I’ve had to ask for help on numerous occasions, and never felt like I was inconveniencing them.
Store is not as well stocked as the website, but that’s understandable considering that it is smallish. Dressing room is actually clean and don’t have dustballs rolling around - my pet peeve.”
“I stopped in today to exchange some items for a larger size. Unfortunately the size I needed was out of stock. Bryan was so helpful, first in checking in back, and then locating what I needed online. He ordered it for me and it will be delivered to my home in just a few days. Thanks for the great customer service, Bryan!”
10AM - 8PM
2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa
Shoe Stores
“I just Want to give a shout out to Mary at Mayfair mall LOFT. I received the best customer Service today. I had. a great time laughing and joking around with Mary. Every time I go on this location, all she is doing is working tirelessly and I always make that comment to her! I hope LOFT appreciates having such an excellent associate! Keep up the great work Mary , see you soon sooner than I should! Lol”
“Matt at Footlocker Mayfair was so kind, helpful and efficient. He helped me make a purchase, signed me up for an account luckily ! Do to a return with missing receipt took my worries away at another store visit. Despite store being very busy and some difficult customers Matt helped with a smile. Thank you! I never write reviews but I hope you get acknowledged for your great customer service !”
“I like kid foot locker because they greet you at the door they ask you how may I help you and I'm always buying something from them and the best thing of all I like to put my stuff on layaway and I thank God for that cuz some people like me we don't always have the money to pay for it right there and then so it help us to buy what we came in to buy shoes that's what I like about kid foot locker door may God bless you and your employees.”
“I stopped into Madewell after seeing a TikTok about a pair of jeans that could work during pregnancy. I hadn’t worn jeans in months, but with the weather getting cooler I knew I needed something comfortable to get me through fall.
I worked with Caitlin D., and she was absolutely wonderful! Not only did she help me find the jeans I came in for, but she also pulled several other pieces I never would have thought to try — and they ended up being bump-friendly at 8 months pregnant. She made the whole experience fun, uplifting, and so easy.
I left the store feeling excited to wear my new clothes instead of discouraged, which says everything about the experience she created. A huge thank you to Caitlin for making shopping such a positive experience during this stage of life!”
“I have been shopping here for years and have seen many faces come and go. All the employees have been very friendly and I love the selection of scrubs and sales.”
“Love shopping at Jills. One problem for us old people. Because of my lower lumbar pain on my back. Had no where to sit. Please have somewhere for us to sit. I will wipe sitting when I am done. Thank you.”
“Large selection of shoes. Difficult to find a pair that fits. I'm normally a 7, but shoes in 6s, 6.5s and 7 all fit because nothing is sized the same among manufacturers.”
“I wish I can give this store more than five stars excellent service Even when the store is crowded they're still excellent service excellent service when you first walk in the door they always greet customers and very professional always happy to look for a shoe for you Even if you got to look for multiple shoes to fit you”
“Karyna provided excellent customer service during my visit to JD Sports. She was friendly, professional, and very efficient at the cashier, making the checkout process quick and smooth.”
“A phenomenal shopping experience! Kay was fantastic, I went shopping with my 7yr and she was extremely patient and helpful. Avery was very knowledgeable and kind! Zach was friendly and greeted us as we entered!”