Car Rental near Island Park, NY

26 locations found near Island Park

“I can’t say enough good things about this place! Matt and his team are amazing. I’ve brought my car here a few times now, and every experience has been great. Matt is super knowledgeable, honest, and always takes the time to explain what’s going on. You can really tell he cares about his customers and takes pride in his work.

His sister, who also works there, is always so kind and welcoming — it’s such a nice family-run shop with a great atmosphere. Every time I get my car back, it’s running perfectly, and I always feel confident it was done right. It’s so rare to find people this trustworthy and dependable. I recommend them to everyone!”

4.7 Superb110 Reviews

“I live locally and needed a rental car for a few days. The team at Island Park NY is great! I booked online which was easy. The best part was how friendly and helpful Lauren, Kristen and crew made the whole process!
Thank you!”

3.9 Good119 Reviews

“Matt has been the greatest!!! He has help me out through the whole process with my car accident. Matt was the man!!! He was very confident and knowledgeable about my whole situation.”

4.9 Superb170 Reviews

“I had a great experience with Empire Rent A Car! Their administrative assistant, Maria, was an absolute pleasure to work with. She handled my issue quickly and efficiently, and her communication throughout the process was excellent. It’s always refreshing to deal with someone so professional and friendly. Highly recommend Empire Rent A Car—especially thanks to Maria for making everything so easy!”

4.7 Superb168 Reviews

“I am now in my second lease with First Class because they are that good at what they do. Doniel was my incredible agent. I couldn't have asked for better service in any way. From start to finish all my questions were answered and all of my needs addressed. I highly recommend this leasing company!”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“Amazing customer service! Rented the Corvette C8 and it drove beautifully and was very smooth and clean. Definitely recommend others to rent from here and will be renting again! 10/10”

4.6 Superb34 Reviews

“I had a great experience with Enterprise Car Rental. The entire process was quick and efficient, which made everything so much easier. The staff were incredibly kind, accommodating, and professional; they really went out of their way to make sure I was taken care of!

The car itself was in great condition, clean, and drove perfectly. You can tell they take pride in both their service and their vehicles. Overall, I couldn’t have asked for a smoother experience and would definitely rent from them again.”

4.1 Good119 Reviews

“I had such a wonderful experience with Enterprise! The representative who helped me was incredibly nice, polite, and genuinely helpful. The whole process was smooth, efficient, and surprisingly quick. It was honestly the best and fastest car rental experience I’ve ever had. I truly appreciated the excellent customer service!”

4 Good166 Reviews

“First time renting from Enterprise as I am a fairly new driver. The manager Jonathan and the two other staff (male and female) all were very kind , patient and professional. They went above and beyond to make sure I left with a vehicle that I felt comfortable in.”

4 Good196 Reviews

“Rented for a month with this location. CARL saved the day every single time it was necessary. There were no complaints with the vehicle or actual service. Any problems that arose he was able to combat them & then some. Thanks again, truly!
- Jahmila”

4 Good141 Reviews

“Joe D'Arco was fantastic, kind and extremely professional. The pick and drop off was friendly and a breeze with him. Highly recommend him for any future rentals. Thank you Joe!”

3.9 Good207 Reviews

“I had an outstanding experience thanks to Darnell at Enterprise. From the moment I walked in, he went above and beyond to make sure everything was smooth, efficient, and stress-free. His professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine customer care truly set him apart. Definitely a TOP TIER experience.??”

3.8 Good166 Reviews

“The best place to find your exotic or special rental. Many of my friends rented vehicles here for their special events, weddings, proms, bridal showers. They will not disappoint.”

5 Superb11 Reviews

“The Staff Employees Was Great And Yes If Needed Would Rent Again But The Deposit Takes To Long To Return Should Be The Same Day Of The Return!! ThomasDeGroat,FarRockaway Queens New York 11691”

3.7 Good176 Reviews

“Eva was amazing got us the rental so fast and she was so helpful, I actually left my 2 wallets in the glove compartment, Eva held them for me until I came back to get them, total honest and very professional I will always rent from this Avis in Lynbrook, Ny thank u so much Eva..”

3.8 Good139 Reviews

“Bought my car from this place. My guys Rick and Ali helped me out a lot. They never lie they say it as it is. If u looking for a car trust me this is the place to go.”

4.4 Superb46 Reviews

“Amidi at this location was the most helpful honorable and honest person that I dealt with after scouring 6 or 7 Enterprise and Avis locations. He had the car that he said he had, and he delivered. The others made me travel to their locations and did not deliver what they said they had. Hopefully, I will only have to deal with a person whose character is like Amidi's if I ever rent a car again. Tx again”

3.6 Good155 Reviews

“Had a great experience with Erik yesterday. He’s a great guy. Informative, funny, understanding, and accommodating. Great place even better sevrvice. Thanks Erik.”

3.6 Good200 Reviews

“My family and I recently moved and my husband had to go to NY for business and rented a car from Zane; if you ever need to rent a car, you should absolutely use Journey Rent A Car! Zane went above and beyond to ensure my husband was using a safe reliable car during his trip back to N.Y.
Zane, thank you so very much for making this process completely seamless and worry free!! We will never rent a car from someone/somewhere else! Thank you!!!!”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“My car broke down 100 miles from home and was in the shop overnight for repairs. Enterprise in Freeport, NY made it very easy and affordable to to rent a car for the night. Trey and the rest of the staff were fabulous.”

3.6 Good154 Reviews

“My experience with Motor Network — and especially Michael Chase — was absolutely flawless. If there were a way to give six stars, I would. From start to finish, it felt less like buying a car and more like having my own personal automotive concierge.

From our very first conversation to the moment my new car was delivered, Mike redefined what customer service should be. There was zero pressure, only honesty, patience, and genuine care. Every single question I had (and trust me, there were plenty!) was answered with incredible professionalism and knowledge.

Mike made the entire process effortless and enjoyable — words I never thought I’d use to describe buying a car. His communication, attention to detail, and commitment to making sure my family and I were comfortable every step of the way were second to none.

I can confidently say I’ll be a Motor Network client for life, and I’ll recommend Michael Chase to anyone who values integrity, service, and excellence. This is how car buying should be done!”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

“Check out and check in was quick, easy, and hassle free. The place is hidden on the bottom level of the holiday in and the entrance is behind the holiday in. I would definitely come here to rent a car again !!”

3.6 Good82 Reviews

“I want to share my appreciation and give a high score to Budget Rent-A-Car. I recently rented a Yukon Denali, and the experience was excellent. The ride was smooth, and the convenience of having E-ZPass already installed made traveling much easier. Since the car was a 2025 model, it had the latest modern technology that was both easy to understand and use.

In addition, the service representative was polite, professional, and took the time to explain the features of the car clearly. Overall, I had a very positive experience and would highly recommend Budget Rent-A-Car.”

3.4 Good108 Reviews

“This location has improved tremendously. They now have more cars available and the staff is a real pleasure! Harry greeted me with a warm smile and was eager to help. He thanked me for my Presidents Circle loyalty and had me in an awesome car within minutes. Thank you Harry & Hertz Inwood, I’ll be returning real soon :)”

3.1 Average62 Reviews

“Very satisfied with the service provided.
Receiving credit for returning vehicle after the NYC blizzard was quite a relief.
Kudos to the Manager.”

3 Average159 Reviews

Related topics