“I went to Middleton Jewelers for a custom necklace. They did an amazing job and kept me informed with each step along the way! I live out of town and was nervous not designing this in person, but it came out perfectly!! Manny is wonderful!”
“We worked with Laura and she was AMAZING! She truly listened to what I liked and didn’t like to find the perfect ring! She took time with us and didn’t make us feel rushed or pressured into anything. We were recommended by my family and I’m so glad we chose Kesslers.”
“Thank you to the whole team for my engagement ring I’ve been trying to add a photo of it but it won’t let me:(. Go there and see bill like I said before! Great guy to work with! Thank you we plan on coming back for the wedding ring soon! Thank you again! Will add photos in photo section”
“We had the most wonderful experience purchasing our engagement ring from TQ Diamonds. Maddie, truly went above and beyond in assisting us. She took the time to understand our preferences and budget, guiding us to the perfect ring that exceeded our expectations. Maddie's attention to detail and genuine care for her customers made us feel confident in our decision. The quality of the diamond and the craftsmanship of the ring are outstanding. We are absolutely thrilled with our choice and grateful for Maddie's expertise. We highly recommend this company to anyone looking for a special piece, especially with a dedicated professional like Maddie to assist you every step of the way!”
“Me and my fiancé just brought our daughter here to get her ears pierced I can’t remember there names but they were the kindest people they made my daughter feel comfortable and she is very excited about her new earrings 10/10 would recommend .”
“Bill and his staff were an absolute pleasure to work with—fair, efficient, helpful. Excellent craftsmanship and exquisite taste in designing my ring: marquis diamond flanked by two small round diamonds in William Thomas signature “Juliet” setting. Gorgeous! I’m thrilled and receive many compliments!”
“This is a great store with plenty of options for funny and sarcastic gifts. I like to buy cards there as they are funnier and less expensive than a card from most other stores. One of the co-owners helped us at checkout, and she was friendly and social. There are no other businesses like this store in the Madison area. It's definitely worth checking out!”
“First time customer. Went in for a new watch battery and was completely impressed from the moment I walked in the door. Beautiful store and was greeted immediately by Jade Darby. Told him why I was there and he treated me like I was making a 6 figure purchase! Offered me water and changed my battery for free! I was in and out of the store in less than 10 minutes. Great store and exceptional customer service. I won't go anywhere else from here on out.”
“My fiance and I went to get a wedding band and Blake was wonderful! He helped us find a beautiful band and fix my engagement ring. He was very helpful, kind, and knowledgeable! Highly recommend for people who don't know a lot about jewelry!”
“Once again they have come through with fine service. Needed an old custom wedding ring modified. Price was right, estimated time frame was acceptable, and they cut that wait in half. The staff were, as usual, very pleasant. They are the first place I consider for jewelry.”
“Very friendly and professional service. Came in not knowing what exactly I wanted but the owner was able to quickly help me find something that fit my description and budget. Will definitely come back in the future”
“I stopped the end to Midwest fine jewelry and I was treated with respect and kindness.. on my very first visit! and it was my birthday. Very knowledgeable out gold and customer service overall five stars. Thank you G.”
“My jaw hit the floor the moment I saw the front window! What a show stopping window!! Everything in the store is so carefully curated with love and appreciation! You just can’t help but stand back and admire it all. And the prices and SO reasonable. I honestly thought I wouldn’t be able to afford anything there but I happily walked away with goodies. Ryan was also so helpful helping me ID a piece I have at home- I love the glass community!”
11AM - 6PM
524 E Washington Ave, Madison
Jewelry Stores
“Five years ago, I bought my wife's engagement ring, wedding band, and my own wedding band from Chalmers. The service was incredible and the jewelry is of exceptional quality.
Because of this positive experience, we recently went back for a 5-year anniversary gift. My wife received wonderful assistance in selecting a few pieces for me to choose from. I worked with Victor to finalize the purchase and make sure that every detail was correct. We love the work Chalmers has done for us and the service they provide.”
“I have purchased jewelry multiple times from Diny’s. I have always had a positive experience and have been treated fairly. They are my go to jeweler in Madison”
“I love visiting this gemmy sparkly shop. The store offers a diverse selection of rocks, minerals, fossils, gemstones, and other geological treasures, making it a haven for collectors, jewelers, and curious minds. The staff at Bernie's Rock Shop are passionate about geology and are eager to assist customers in finding or crafting the perfect piece for their collections, or as thoughtful gifts and also jewelry repairs.Thank you!”
“Stopped by becuase of the interests we have.
My daughter and I entered the store for the first time. We were both greeted warmly and asked if there was any we were interested in. I virtually never leave a store as this type without purchasing something.
I stated I wasn't sure and the stated in the same tone and volume I had just finished working.
The owner/ manager and employee turned to each other and started to chat. No worries. We browsed the store and I needed a quite replacement item and I found it. My daughter picked up a couple of items.
The store is well organized and seems to cater to a variety of clientele. Parking is sufficient.”
“Fair, high quality, personal. Lee has repaired a few items of mine at a very fair price. His collection is unique and varied (in a good way). No high pressure sales and no games.”
“Tim at Earth Elements was fantastic to work with! He really listened to what I wanted, offered creative ideas, and incorporated every detail perfectly. The results were spot on — exactly what I envisioned. Highly recommend Tim for his talent, professionalism, and attention to detail!”
“5/23/25 was my first visit to your shop. There is an amazingly beautiful selection of crystals, rocks, and tons of other hands crafted items here. I like the wind-chime selection here. The ladies were so helpful and filled with knowledgeable info. So many great items here for reasonable prices. We will recommend this place and come back as often as we can. My daughter absolutely loved her purple carved dragon. Thank you for having such a calming atmosphere.”
“I highly recommend this company for a reliable, easy transaction with beautiful listings.
The customer service is top notch, as well. I spoke with Josh to resolve a payment issue, and I couldn’t have asked for a better conversation.
Again, highly recommended company to do business with.”
“I made a visit to Kay Jewelers today in West Towne Mall, and Anthony worked his magic and left me satisfied. I have been coming to Kay for many years and he has never done anything but provide excellent service 10/10”
“Had my long time nose piercing fall out randomly, went to several shops to find a replacement and no other place had the price or selection STUDS has! Plus the staff was awesome.”
“Burnie's, both locations are just great, always full of treasures and surprises. When my son who is now 11, was 2, all he wanted in the world was a piece of amber with a bug in it. Eventually, off to Burnie's we went. He subsequently lost the item in a tragic, "I hide it from my friends in a trash can so nobody would take it" incident. Years later, on another magical Burnie's expedition, we mentioned the funny story, and Ben said he had an idea of how to fix the situation. There are very few places that can fix the injuries of childhood. Well played Burnie's, well played. Always a pleasure to visit your treasures.”
“I couldn’t be happier with how my fiancé’s engagement ring turned out. Being a guy who’s never bought any jewelry before, let alone an engagement ring, made it really difficult to know where to start. I really wanted to surprise her but all I had was a picture of what she sort of wanted. Brian helped me through it all. He was patient, accommodating, and professional in every way. He did such an incredible job by breaking everything down for me, giving me options, and really bringing her dream ring to life. This ring does not go unnoticed. Not two minutes after getting engaged she was already getting compliments on it. We both couldn’t be happier with the ring. I would definitely recommend BR Diamond Suites and their staff for any of your jewelry needs!”
10AM - 6PM
6202 University Ave, Middleton
Jewelry Stores
“Great place, great customer service, great value. Special thanks to Kelvin. He is very professional and friendly. Thanks for everything. I’m looking forward to do more business. Top notch ?”
“Good Day Shop is my favorite place to buy gifts! I always find something unique and well made. The store is warm and inviting and everyone who works there is so sweet. I’m currently loving their holiday display!”
“I appreciate vintage and estate jewelry; I primarily purchase from resellers on Instagram. I was in Madison last week and found University Coin & Jewelry with a quick online search. I had so much fun shopping the extensive selection with help from Rhonda and Dave. The selection was extensive and the staff was very knowledgeable, nice, and knew the inventory. They were helpful but didn't pressure me. I found some great treasures. It's a full service situation, too, as they were able to size a ring I selected. If you like estate and vintage jewelry, stop by and check out the treasures!”
“This place is magical! It has amazing energy, beautiful crystals and spiritual products .Lydia is the best! She is super knowledgeble and went above and beyond to help us!”
“1000/10 recommend working with Soha Diamond Co! Aubree and Soha were the absolute best - the process of designing a timeless engagement ring that was exactly how we envisioned it was so seamless and they totally delivered!! The ring is even better than I dreamed it to be - they really brought it to life! It’s so expertly crafted and has all the little details we wanted ? HUGE thank you to Soha and Aubree! We will absolutely be back for more pieces in the future!!”